Thomas Anita A, Uspal Neil G, Oron Assaf P, Klein Eileen J
J Grad Med Educ. 2016 Dec;8(5):754-758. doi: 10.4300/JGME-D-15-00730.1.
Just-in-time (JIT) training refers to education occurring immediately prior to clinical encounters. An in situ JIT room in a pediatric emergency department (ED) was created for procedural education.
We examined trainee self-reported JIT room use, its impact on trainee self-perception of procedural competence/confidence, and the effect its usage has on the need for intervention by supervising physicians during procedures.
Cross-sectional survey study of a convenience sample of residents rotating through the ED and supervising pediatric emergency medicine physicians. Outcomes included JIT room use, trainee procedural confidence, and frequency of supervisor intervention during procedures.
Thirty-one of 32 supervising physicians (97%) and 122 of 186 residents (66%) completed the survey, with 71% of trainees reporting improved confidence, and 68% reporting improved procedural skills ( < .05, +1.4-point average skills improvement on a 5-point Likert scale). Trainees perceived no difference among supervising physicians intervening in procedures with or without JIT room use ( = .30, paired difference -0.0 points). Nearly all supervisors reported improved trainee procedural confidence, and 77% reported improved trainee procedural skills after JIT room use ( < .05, paired difference +1.8 points); 58% of supervisors stated they intervene in procedures without trainee JIT room use, compared with 42% with JIT room use ( < .05, paired difference -0.4 points).
Use of the JIT room led to improved trainee confidence and supervisor reports of less procedural intervention. Although it carries financial and time costs, an in situ JIT room may be important for convenient JIT training.
即时(JIT)培训是指在临床接触前即刻进行的教育。在儿科急诊科设立了一个现场即时培训室用于操作培训。
我们研究了学员自我报告的即时培训室使用情况、其对学员操作能力/信心自我认知的影响,以及其使用对操作过程中带教医师进行干预需求的影响。
对在急诊科轮转的住院医师和儿科急诊医学带教医师的便利样本进行横断面调查研究。结果包括即时培训室使用情况、学员操作信心以及操作过程中带教医师干预的频率。
32名带教医师中的31名(97%)和186名住院医师中的122名(66%)完成了调查,71%的学员报告信心有所提高,68%报告操作技能有所提高(P<0.05,在5分制李克特量表上平均技能提高1.4分)。学员认为带教医师在有或没有使用即时培训室的情况下进行操作干预没有差异(P=0.30,配对差异为-0.0分)。几乎所有带教医师都报告学员使用即时培训室后操作信心有所提高;77%报告学员操作技能有所提高(P<0.05;配对差异为+1.8分);58%的带教医师表示在学员未使用即时培训室时会在操作中进行干预,而使用即时培训室时这一比例为42%(P<0.05,配对差异为-0.4分)。
使用即时培训室提高了学员的信心,带教医师报告的操作干预减少。尽管它存在财务和时间成本,但现场即时培训室对于便捷的即时培训可能很重要。