Burov Stanislav, Figliozzi Patrick, Lin Binhua, Rice Stuart A, Scherer Norbert F, Dinner Aaron R
Department of Physics, Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan 5290002, Israel.
James Franck Institute, The University of Chicago, Chicago, IL 60637.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2017 Jan 10;114(2):221-226. doi: 10.1073/pnas.1619104114. Epub 2016 Dec 27.
We present a general method for detecting and correcting biases in the outputs of particle-tracking experiments. Our approach is based on the histogram of estimated positions within pixels, which we term the single-pixel interior filling function (SPIFF). We use the deviation of the SPIFF from a uniform distribution to test the veracity of tracking analyses from different algorithms. Unbiased SPIFFs correspond to uniform pixel filling, whereas biased ones exhibit pixel locking, in which the estimated particle positions concentrate toward the centers of pixels. Although pixel locking is a well-known phenomenon, we go beyond existing methods to show how the SPIFF can be used to correct errors. The key is that the SPIFF aggregates statistical information from many single-particle images and localizations that are gathered over time or across an ensemble, and this information augments the single-particle data. We explicitly consider two cases that give rise to significant errors in estimated particle locations: undersampling the point spread function due to small emitter size and intensity overlap of proximal objects. In these situations, we show how errors in positions can be corrected essentially completely with little added computational cost. Additional situations and applications to experimental data are explored in SI Appendix In the presence of experimental-like shot noise, the precision of the SPIFF-based correction achieves (and can even exceed) the unbiased Cramér-Rao lower bound. We expect the SPIFF approach to be useful in a wide range of localization applications, including single-molecule imaging and particle tracking, in fields ranging from biology to materials science to astronomy.
我们提出了一种用于检测和校正粒子跟踪实验输出偏差的通用方法。我们的方法基于像素内估计位置的直方图,我们将其称为单像素内部填充函数(SPIFF)。我们使用SPIFF与均匀分布的偏差来测试不同算法的跟踪分析的准确性。无偏差的SPIFF对应于均匀的像素填充,而有偏差的SPIFF则表现出像素锁定,即估计的粒子位置集中在像素中心。尽管像素锁定是一个众所周知的现象,但我们超越了现有方法,展示了如何使用SPIFF来校正误差。关键在于SPIFF汇总了来自许多单粒子图像以及随时间或跨集合收集的定位的统计信息,并且该信息增强了单粒子数据。我们明确考虑了两种在估计粒子位置时会产生重大误差的情况:由于发射体尺寸小导致点扩散函数欠采样以及近端物体的强度重叠。在这些情况下,我们展示了如何以几乎不增加计算成本的方式基本完全校正位置误差。SI附录中探讨了其他情况以及对实验数据的应用。在存在类似实验散粒噪声的情况下,基于SPIFF的校正精度达到(甚至可以超过)无偏差的克拉美 - 罗下界。我们期望SPIFF方法在从生物学到材料科学再到天文学等广泛的定位应用中有用,包括单分子成像和粒子跟踪。