Sparks David S, Read Tavis, Lonne Michael, Barbour Andrew P, Wagels Michael, Bayley Gerard J, Smithers B Mark
Princess Alexandra Hospital, Woolloongabba, Queensland, Australia.
PA-Southside Clinical School, School of Medicine, The University of Queensland, Woolloongabba, Queensland, Australia.
J Surg Oncol. 2017 Mar;115(4):449-454. doi: 10.1002/jso.24535. Epub 2016 Dec 30.
Patients with primary melanoma of the scalp have been reported to have worse disease-related outcomes compared with other anatomical regions. There are few studies in the literature specifically addressing recurrence patterns and treatment outcomes for primary scalp melanoma as a discrete anatomical sub-region. We sought to identify key features adversely influencing disease control and survival and to clarify the role of resection plane, margin, and method of reconstruction in the management of this disease process.
A retrospective clinical study of medical records was performed evaluating all patients with primary melanoma of the scalp treated at two hospitals in southeast Queensland between 2004 and 2014.
A total of 107 patients were eligible for analysis. There were 46 recurrences in 38 patients in the cohort accounting for a recurrence rate of 35.5%. The local recurrence rate was 15.9% with 12 in-transit metastases after diagnosis. Regional and distant recurrence rates were 12.1% and 15%, respectively. At a median follow up of 30.5 months, disease-free survival was 47% and overall survival was also 47%. On multi-variate analysis, the deeper resection plane (sub-galeal) had a lower disease-free survival rate compared with the supra-galeal resection plane (P = 0.032).
Our results support the hypothesis that primary scalp melanoma represents a unique aggressive subcategory with high rates of in-transit disease and poor disease-related and survival outcomes. There is a need for robust prospective comparative studies to address the significance of resection plane in the management of patients with scalp melanoma.
据报道,与其他解剖部位相比,头皮原发性黑色素瘤患者的疾病相关预后较差。文献中很少有专门针对原发性头皮黑色素瘤作为一个独立解剖亚区域的复发模式和治疗结果的研究。我们试图确定对疾病控制和生存产生不利影响的关键特征,并阐明切除平面、切缘和重建方法在该疾病治疗过程中的作用。
对昆士兰东南部两家医院在2004年至2014年期间治疗的所有原发性头皮黑色素瘤患者的病历进行回顾性临床研究。
共有107例患者符合分析条件。该队列中有38例患者出现46次复发,复发率为35.5%。局部复发率为15.9%,诊断后有12例发生皮下转移。区域和远处复发率分别为12.1%和15%。中位随访30.5个月时,无病生存率为47%,总生存率也为47%。多变量分析显示,与帽状腱膜上切除平面相比,更深的切除平面(帽状腱膜下)的无病生存率较低(P = 0.032)。
我们的结果支持这样的假设,即原发性头皮黑色素瘤是一个独特的侵袭性亚类,皮下转移率高,疾病相关和生存结果较差。需要进行强有力的前瞻性比较研究,以探讨切除平面在头皮黑色素瘤患者治疗中的意义。