Moura Diogo, Fonseca Fernando
Centro Hospitalar e Universitário de Coimbra, Departamento de Ortopedia, Coimbra, Portugal.
Rev Bras Ortop. 2016 Oct 25;51(6):640-645. doi: 10.1016/j.rboe.2016.10.012. eCollection 2016 Nov-Dec.
This was a retrospective case-control study on total ruptures of the extensor apparatus of the knee, aimed to compare patella fractures with tendinous ruptures.
The sample included 190 patients and 198 total ruptures of the knee extensor apparatus. All patients were evaluated by the same examiner after a minimum one-year follow-up.
Tendinous ruptures occurred most frequently in men, in younger patients, and had better clinical and functional outcomes when compared with patella fractures; however, the former presented higher levels of thigh atrophy. Patella fractures occurred most frequently in women and in older patients and caused most frequently caused residual pain, muscle weakness, and limitations in daily activities. Comminuted fractures were related to high-energy trauma, lower clinical and functional outcomes, and higher levels of residual pain and osteosynthesis failure. Early removal of osteosynthesis material was related to better outcomes. Regarding the tendinous ruptures, over half of the patients presented risk conditions for tendinous degeneration; a longer delay until surgery was related to lower Kujala scores.
The surgical repair of bilateral ruptures of the knee extensor apparatus resulted in satisfactory clinical and functional outcomes, which were better for tendinous ruptures when compared with patella fractures. However, these lesions are associated with non-negligible levels of residual pain, muscle weakness, atrophy, and other complications.
这是一项关于膝部伸肌装置完全断裂的回顾性病例对照研究,旨在比较髌骨骨折与肌腱断裂情况。
样本包括190例患者及198例膝部伸肌装置完全断裂病例。所有患者均在至少1年随访后由同一名检查者进行评估。
肌腱断裂在男性及年轻患者中最为常见,与髌骨骨折相比,其临床和功能预后更好;然而,前者大腿萎缩程度更高。髌骨骨折在女性及老年患者中最为常见,最常导致残留疼痛、肌肉无力及日常活动受限。粉碎性骨折与高能创伤、较低的临床和功能预后以及较高的残留疼痛水平和骨合成失败有关。早期取出骨合成材料与更好的预后相关。关于肌腱断裂,超过半数患者存在肌腱退变的风险因素;手术延迟时间越长,Kujala评分越低。
膝部伸肌装置双侧断裂的手术修复取得了令人满意的临床和功能预后,与髌骨骨折相比,肌腱断裂的预后更好。然而,这些损伤伴有不可忽视的残留疼痛、肌肉无力、萎缩及其他并发症。