Perkins Matthew J, Snesrud Erik, McGann Patrick, Duplessis Christopher A
Infectious Diseases Clinic, Walter Reed National Military Medical Center, 8960 Brown Drive, Bethesda, MD 20889.
Walter Reed Army Institute of Research, 503 Robert Grant Avenue, Silver Spring, MD 20910.
Mil Med. 2017 Jan;182(1):e1669-e1672. doi: 10.7205/MILMED-D-15-00535.
We report a case of successful treatment of chronic osteomyelitis (emanating from contaminated soil exposure) caused by Clostridium sphenoides, an organism infrequently identified as a cause of human infection and more saliently osteomyelitis (only 1 reported case in the literature). Additional impetus for reporting this case resides in the insights gained regarding pathogen identification exploiting sophisticated molecular platforms coupled to traditional microbial culture-based methods. The fastidious nature of cultivating anaerobic organisms required initial attempts at 16S rRNA sequencing to identify a Clostridium species (Clostridium celerecrescens). However, on exploiting matrix-assisted laser desorption ionization time of flight (MALDI TOF) technology, C. sphenoides was identified, and confirmed on whole genome sequencing. The discrepancies noted in the varying platforms require vigilance to seek complementary testing for conflicting results. Although highly accurate, the MALDI TOF and 16S rRNA sequencing platforms are not immune to false identification particularly in differentiating closely related organisms. More germane, whole genome sequencing should be entertained when conflicting results are obtained from MALDI TOF and 16S rRNA sequencing. Precise species and/or strain level identification can be clinically relevant as antimicrobial sensitivity profiles may be discrepant between closely related species influencing clinical outcomes. Thus, it is incumbent on us to strive to acquire the correct species characterization when resources allow to dictate optimal treatment.
我们报告了一例成功治疗由蝶形梭菌引起的慢性骨髓炎(因接触受污染土壤所致)的病例,该菌很少被鉴定为人类感染的病因,更显著的是骨髓炎的病因(文献中仅报道过1例)。报告此病例的另一个原因是,利用先进的分子平台与传统的基于微生物培养的方法相结合,在病原体鉴定方面获得了一些见解。培养厌氧生物的苛求性使得最初尝试通过16S rRNA测序来鉴定一种梭菌属物种(快速生长梭菌)。然而,利用基质辅助激光解吸电离飞行时间(MALDI TOF)技术鉴定出了蝶形梭菌,并通过全基因组测序得到了证实。不同平台上发现的差异需要警惕,以便对相互矛盾的结果进行补充检测。尽管MALDI TOF和16S rRNA测序平台高度准确,但它们也并非不会出现错误鉴定,尤其是在区分密切相关的生物体时。更相关的是,当从MALDI TOF和16S rRNA测序获得相互矛盾的结果时,应考虑进行全基因组测序。精确的物种和/或菌株水平鉴定在临床上可能具有相关性,因为密切相关物种之间的抗菌敏感性谱可能不同,从而影响临床结果。因此,在资源允许的情况下,我们有责任努力获得正确的物种特征,以指导最佳治疗。