Waduud Mohammed A, Sharaf Amal, Roy Iain, Lopez-Gonzalez Rosario, Hart Andrew, McGill David, Roditi Giles, Biddlestone John
1 Canniesburn Plastic Surgery Unit, Glasgow Royal Infirmary, Glasgow, UK.
2 Department of Radiology, Glasgow Royal Infirmary, Glasgow, UK.
Br J Radiol. 2017 Mar;90(1071):20160662. doi: 10.1259/bjr.20160662. Epub 2017 Jan 5.
A valid method for accurate quantification of abdominal fat distribution (AFD) using both CT and MRI is described. This method will be primarily useful in the prospective risk stratification of patients undergoing reconstructive breast surgery. Secondary applications in many other clinical specialities are foreseen.
15 sequential patients who had undergone breast reconstruction following both CT and MRI (30 scans) were retrospectively identified at our single centre. The AFD was quantified at the level of the L3 vertebra. Image analysis was performed by at least two independent operators using free software. Intra- and interobserver differences were assessed using Bland-Altman plots. Data were validated between imaging modalities by Pearson's correlation. Linear regression analyses were used to mathematically normalize results between imaging modalities.
The method was statistically independent of rater bias (intra: Pearson's R-0.954-1.00; inter: 0.799-0.999). Strong relationships between imaging modalities were demonstrated and are independent of time between imaging (Pearson's R 0.625-0.903). Interchangeable mathematical models to normalize between imaging modality are shown.
The method described is highly reproducible and independent of rater bias. A strong interchangeable relationship exists between calculations of AFD on retrospective CT and MRI. Advances in knowledge: This is the first technique to be applicable to scans that are not performed sequentially or in a research setting. Analysis is semi-automated and results can be compared directly, regardless of imaging modality or patient position. This method has clinical utility in prospective risk stratification and will be applicable to many clinical specialities.
描述一种利用CT和MRI准确量化腹部脂肪分布(AFD)的有效方法。该方法主要有助于对接受乳房重建手术的患者进行前瞻性风险分层。预计在许多其他临床专科也有次要应用。
在我们的单一中心回顾性确定了15例先后接受CT和MRI检查(共30次扫描)并进行乳房重建的连续患者。在L3椎体水平对AFD进行量化。由至少两名独立操作人员使用免费软件进行图像分析。使用Bland-Altman图评估观察者内和观察者间差异。通过Pearson相关性在不同成像方式之间验证数据。使用线性回归分析对不同成像方式的结果进行数学归一化。
该方法在统计学上与评分者偏差无关(观察者内:Pearson's R - 0.954 - 1.00;观察者间:0.799 - 0.999)。不同成像方式之间显示出很强的相关性,且与成像之间的时间无关(Pearson's R 0.625 - 0.903)。展示了用于在不同成像方式之间进行归一化的可互换数学模型。
所描述的方法具有高度可重复性且与评分者偏差无关。回顾性CT和MRI上AFD计算之间存在很强的可互换关系。知识进展:这是第一种适用于非顺序进行或非研究环境下扫描的技术。分析是半自动的,结果可直接比较,无论成像方式或患者体位如何。该方法在前瞻性风险分层中具有临床实用性,并且将适用于许多临床专科。