Zheng Y M, Yang J, Liao Q H
Division of Infectious Disease, Key Laboratory of Surveillance and Early Warning on Infectious Disease, Chinese Center for Disease Control and Prevention, Beijing 102206, China.
Zhonghua Yu Fang Yi Xue Za Zhi. 2017 Jan 6;51(1):87-92. doi: 10.3760/cma.j.issn.0253-9624.2017.01.017.
To estimate the direct medical cost of severe hand, foot and mouth disease (HFMD) in patients aged less than five years. A stratified sampling method was used to collect data on severe HFMD cases reported in the National HFMD surveillance database between Jan 1, 2012, and Dec 31, 2013. The sampling was referenced with the national aetiologic distribution of Enterovirus A71 (EV-A71), Coxsackievirus A16 (CV-A16) and other Enteroviruses (OEV) for severe HFMD cases and the included cases were distributed among seven geographic regions (Northeast, North China, Northwest, Central China, Southwest, East China and South China). A nationwide telephone interview using a structured questionnaire was conducted to obtain the direct medical cost and any complications that occurred in patients during the outbreak of laboratory-confirmed HFMD. After excluding the cases who could not recall their medical expenses or complications, a total of 685 cases were included in the analysis. Kruskal-Wallis test was used to analyze the differences among patients who reported different complications. Multiple linear regression with bootstrap analysis of 500 replicates was used to explore the factors that influenced the direct medical costs. Of 685 patients analyzed, 456 (66.6%) were male and 229 (33.4%) were female. The direct medical costs (, ) were 14 250 (10 301, 20 600) Yuan. In total, 127 (18.5%) patients were diagnosed with severe HFMD patients with respiratory disease, 38 (5.5%) patients were diagnosed with aseptic meningitis, and 378 (55.2%) with encephalitis/brainstem encephalitis/acute flaccid paralysis. Furthermore, 53 (18.5%) patients were diagnosed with myocarditis, 39 (5.7%) with pulmonary hemorrhage/pulmonary edema and 50 (7.3%) with cardiopulmonary failure. The median (interquartile range) direct medical costs were 12 360 (7 313, 16 480) Yuan for severe HFMD patients with respiratory disease, 13 803 (9 064, 19 930) Yuan for aseptic meningitis, 14 438 (11 000, 20 015) Yuan for encephalitis/brainstem encephalitis/acute flaccid paralysis, 14 800 (8 500, 21 218) Yuan for myocarditis, 20 600 (12 500, 31 130) Yuan for pulmonary hemorrhage/pulmonary edema, and 20 043 (12 772, 28 840) Yuan for cardiopulmonary failure (17.70, <0.001). The results of multiple linear regression with bootstrap analysis revealed that the direct medical cost for severe HFMD patients from Central China was 7 881 (95% 3 814-11 949) Yuan higher than that of North China; severe HFMD patients diagnosed with OEV had direct medical costs of 1 987 (95% 206-3 769) Yuan less those associated with EV-A71; severe HFMD patients whose duration of illness was ≥21 d had 20 480 (95% 10 985- 29 974) Yuan higher direct medical costs those whose illness lasted ≤5 d; the direct medical costs for severe HFMD patients with pulmonary hemorrhage/pulmonary edema and cardiopulmonary failure were 7 874 (95% 3 723-12 026) and 9 855 (95% 328- 19 382) Yuan higher, respectively, than that associated with respiratory disease. The direct medical costs associated with severe HFMD were found to be substantial. The total cost was affected by the duration of the illness and the severity of any complications.
估算5岁以下重症手足口病(HFMD)患者的直接医疗费用。采用分层抽样方法收集2012年1月1日至2013年12月31日期间国家手足口病监测数据库中报告的重症手足口病病例数据。抽样参考了重症手足口病病例中肠道病毒A71(EV - A71)、柯萨奇病毒A16(CV - A16)和其他肠道病毒(OEV)的全国病原学分布情况,纳入病例分布在七个地理区域(东北、华北、西北、华中、西南、华东和华南)。通过结构化问卷进行全国范围的电话访谈,以获取实验室确诊手足口病疫情期间患者的直接医疗费用及发生的任何并发症。在排除无法回忆医疗费用或并发症的病例后,共685例病例纳入分析。采用Kruskal - Wallis检验分析报告不同并发症患者之间的差异。使用重复500次的Bootstrap分析进行多元线性回归,以探讨影响直接医疗费用的因素。在分析的685例患者中,456例(66.6%)为男性,229例(33.4%)为女性。直接医疗费用(中位数,四分位间距)为14250(10301,20600)元。总计127例(18.5%)患者被诊断为伴有呼吸系统疾病的重症手足口病患者,38例(5.5%)患者被诊断为无菌性脑膜炎,378例(55.2%)患者被诊断为脑炎/脑干脑炎/急性弛缓性麻痹。此外,53例(18.5%)患者被诊断为心肌炎,39例(5.7%)患者被诊断为肺出血/肺水肿,50例(7.3%)患者被诊断为心肺衰竭。伴有呼吸系统疾病的重症手足口病患者的直接医疗费用中位数(四分位间距)为12360(7313,16480)元,无菌性脑膜炎患者为13803(9064,19930)元,脑炎/脑干脑炎/急性弛缓性麻痹患者为14438(11000,20015)元,心肌炎患者为14800(8500,21218)元,肺出血/肺水肿患者为20600(12500,31130)元;心肺衰竭患者为20043(12772,28840)元(P = 17.70,<0.001)。Bootstrap分析的多元线性回归结果显示,华中地区的重症手足口病患者的直接医疗费用比华北地区高7881(95%置信区间3814 - 11949)元;诊断为OEV的重症手足口病患者的直接医疗费用比与EV - A71相关的患者少1987(95%置信区间206 - 3769)元;病程≥21天的重症手足口病患者的直接医疗费用比病程≤5天的患者高20480(95%置信区间10985 - 29974)元;伴有肺出血/肺水肿和心肺衰竭的重症手足口病患者的直接医疗费用分别比伴有呼吸系统疾病的患者高7874(95%置信区间3723 - 12026)元和9855(95%置信区间328 - 19382)元。研究发现,重症手足口病的直接医疗费用很高。总费用受病程和任何并发症严重程度的影响。