Church Todd D, Jessup Jeffrey P, Guillory Villa L, Vandewalle Kraig S
Gen Dent. 2017 Jan-Feb;65(1):48-52.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the translucency and strength of highly translucent monolithic zirconia ceramic materials recently introduced to the market. Four monolithic zirconium oxide materials promoted as having high translucency (BruxZir Shaded 16, BruxZir HT, Lava Plus, and inCoris TZI C) were compared to a high-translucency, lithium disilicate monolithic glass-ceramic material (IPS e.max CAD HT). To evaluate translucency, the materials were sectioned into 0.5-, 1.0-, 1.5-, and 2.0-mm-thick specimens; all were sintered and polished. Translucency parameters were calculated with a spectrophotometer. To evaluate flexural strength and modulus, the ceramic materials were sectioned to create beams and fractured in a universal testing machine. The lithium disilicate had significantly greater translucency than the zirconia materials at each thickness. In general, the translucencies of the zirconia materials were similar at each thickness. However, at the manufacturers' recommended minimal thicknesses, 0.5-mm specimens of BruxZir Shaded 16, inCoris TZI C, and Lava Plus were more translucent than the 1.0-mm-thick specimens of IPS e.max CAD HT. Translucency significantly decreased for each material at each increase in thickness. The flexural strengths of the zirconia materials were similar to each other and significantly greater than that of IPS e.max CAD HT. Flexural moduli were more variable. Of the zirconia materials, BruxZir Shaded 16 had an overall better combination of translucency, strength, and modulus.
本研究的目的是评估最近推向市场的高透明度整体式氧化锆陶瓷材料的透明度和强度。将四种号称具有高透明度的整体式氧化锆材料(BruxZir Shaded 16、BruxZir HT、Lava Plus和inCoris TZI C)与一种高透明度的整体式二硅酸锂微晶玻璃材料(IPS e.max CAD HT)进行比较。为了评估透明度,将这些材料切割成厚度为0.5毫米、1.0毫米、1.5毫米和2.0毫米的试样;所有试样均经过烧结和抛光处理。使用分光光度计计算透明度参数。为了评估抗弯强度和模量,将陶瓷材料切割成梁状,并在万能试验机上使其断裂。在每种厚度下,二硅酸锂的透明度均显著高于氧化锆材料。一般来说,氧化锆材料在每种厚度下的透明度相似。然而,在制造商推荐的最小厚度下,BruxZir Shaded 16、inCoris TZI C和Lava Plus的0.5毫米试样比IPS e.max CAD HT的1.0毫米厚试样更透明。每种材料的透明度均随厚度增加而显著降低。氧化锆材料的抗弯强度彼此相似,且显著高于IPS e.max CAD HT。抗弯模量的变化更大。在氧化锆材料中,BruxZir Shaded 16在透明度、强度和模量方面的综合表现总体上更好。