Liu Kai, Watanabe Etsurou, Kokubo Hironori
Pharmaceutical Research Division, Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Limited, 26-1, Muraoka-Higashi 2-chome, Fujisawa, Kanagawa, 251-8555, Japan.
J Comput Aided Mol Des. 2017 Feb;31(2):201-211. doi: 10.1007/s10822-016-0005-2. Epub 2017 Jan 10.
The binding mode prediction is of great importance to structure-based drug design. The discrimination of various binding poses of ligand generated by docking is a great challenge not only to docking score functions but also to the relatively expensive free energy calculation methods. Here we systematically analyzed the stability of various ligand poses under molecular dynamics (MD) simulation. First, a data set of 120 complexes was built based on the typical physicochemical properties of drug-like ligands. Three potential binding poses (one correct pose and two decoys) were selected for each ligand from self-docking in addition to the experimental pose. Then, five independent MD simulations for each pose were performed with different initial velocities for the statistical analysis. Finally, the stabilities of ligand poses under MD were evaluated and compared with the native one from crystal structure. We found that about 94% of the native poses were maintained stable during the simulations, which suggests that MD simulations are accurate enough to judge most experimental binding poses as stable properly. Interestingly, incorrect decoy poses were maintained much less and 38-44% of decoys could be excluded just by performing equilibrium MD simulations, though 56-62% of decoys were stable. The computationally-heavy binding free energy calculation can be performed only for these survived poses.
结合模式预测对于基于结构的药物设计至关重要。区分由对接产生的配体的各种结合构象不仅对对接评分函数,而且对相对昂贵的自由能计算方法都是巨大的挑战。在此,我们系统地分析了分子动力学(MD)模拟下各种配体构象的稳定性。首先,基于类药物配体的典型物理化学性质构建了一个包含120个复合物的数据集。除了实验构象外,还从自对接中为每个配体选择了三个潜在结合构象(一个正确构象和两个诱饵构象)。然后,对每个构象进行五次独立的MD模拟,采用不同的初始速度进行统计分析。最后,评估MD下配体构象的稳定性,并与晶体结构中的天然构象进行比较。我们发现,在模拟过程中约94%的天然构象保持稳定,这表明MD模拟足够准确,能够正确地将大多数实验结合构象判断为稳定。有趣的是,不正确的诱饵构象保持稳定的比例要低得多,尽管56 - 62%的诱饵构象是稳定的,但仅通过进行平衡MD模拟就可以排除38 - 44%的诱饵构象。只有对这些存活下来的构象才能进行计算量较大的结合自由能计算。