Sando Mark J, Rajaee Sean S, Liu Joseph P, Banffy Michael, Limpisvasti Orr, Crues John V
1 Orthopaedic Medical Group of Tampa Bay, Tampa, FL.
2 Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Cedars Sinai Medical Center, 444 San Vicente Blvd, No. 603, Los Angeles, CA 90048.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2017 Mar;208(3):W121-W126. doi: 10.2214/AJR.16.17080. Epub 2017 Jan 11.
The purpose of this study was to compare standard knee arthroscopic and MRI findings and measurements for visualization of the femoral condyle articular cartilage. The hypothesis was that certain posterior cartilage defects identified with MRI may not be accessible with routine arthroscopy.
Six cadaveric knees were examined by routine arthroscopy through standard inferomedial and inferolateral portals. Suture anchors were inserted into the femoral condyles at 30°, 60°, 90°, and 120° of flexion as markers of the cartilage surface at the most posterior aspect of the condyle that could be accessed at each degree of flexion. Each specimen was then examined with 3-T MRI and gross dissection. Measurements were obtained and compared.
During arthroscopy at 90° of knee flexion, only 5.83 mm of the medial femoral condyle and 6.83 mm of the lateral femoral condyle were visualized posterior to the anchor placed at 90° of flexion. These arthroscopic measurements were statistically significant underestimates of the actual amount of cartilage identified posterior to the 90° anchor at gross dissection (medial condyle, 44.20 mm; lateral condyle, 37.50 mm) and MRI (medial, 41.33 mm; lateral, 38.87 mm). This indicates that 85.9% of the medial and 81.8% of the lateral posterior articular cartilage of the femoral condyle seen at MRI were not visualized during arthroscopy.
More than 80% of the articular cartilage proximal to the menisci seen at MRI is not visible during routine arthroscopy. This far posterior articular cartilage should be called the hidden zone.
本研究旨在比较标准膝关节镜检查与MRI检查结果及测量值,以观察股骨髁关节软骨。假设是MRI识别出的某些后方软骨缺损在常规关节镜检查中可能无法观察到。
通过标准的内侧下和外侧下入口对6具尸体膝关节进行常规关节镜检查。在屈膝30°、60°、90°和120°时将缝合锚钉插入股骨髁,作为在每个屈膝角度可观察到的髁最后方软骨表面的标记。然后对每个标本进行3-T MRI检查和大体解剖。获取测量值并进行比较。
在膝关节屈曲90°的关节镜检查中,在90°屈膝时放置的锚钉后方,内侧股骨髁仅能观察到5.83 mm,外侧股骨髁仅能观察到6.83 mm。这些关节镜测量值在统计学上显著低估了在大体解剖(内侧髁,44.20 mm;外侧髁,37.50 mm)和MRI检查(内侧,41.33 mm;外侧,38.87 mm)中90°锚钉后方实际观察到的软骨量。这表明在MRI上观察到的股骨髁内侧和外侧后方关节软骨,在关节镜检查中分别有85.9%和81.8%未被观察到。
MRI上观察到的半月板近端的关节软骨,在常规关节镜检查中有超过80%不可见。这个非常靠后的关节软骨应被称为隐藏区。