Araujo Miguel, Moraga Cecilia, Chapman Evelina, Barreto Jorge, Illanes Eduardo
Clínica INDISA, Santiago, Chile.
Ministerio de Salud, Santiago, Chile.
Rev Panam Salud Publica. 2016 Nov;40(5):371-381.
Synthesize evidence on effectiveness of interventions designed to improve access to health services by indigenous populations.
Review of systematic reviews published as of July 2015, selecting and analyzing only studies in the Region of the Americas. The bibliographic search encompassed MEDLINE, Lilacs, SciELO, EMBASE, DARE, HTA, The Cochrane Library, and organization websites. Two independent reviewers selected studies and analyzed their methodological quality. A narrative summary of the results was produced.
Twenty-two reviews met the inclusion criteria. All selected studies were conducted in Canada and the United States of America. The majority of the interventions were preventive, to surmount geographical barriers, increase use of effective measures, develop human resources, and improve people's skills or willingness to seek care. Topics included pregnancy, cardiovascular risk factors, diabetes, substance abuse, child development, cancer, mental health, oral health, and injuries. Some interventions showed effectiveness with moderate or high quality studies: educational strategies to prevent depression, interventions to prevent childhood caries, and multicomponent programs to promote use of child safety seats. In general, results for chronic non-communicable diseases were negative or inconsistent.
Interventions do exist that have potential for producing positive effects on access to health services by indigenous populations in the Americas, but available studies are limited to Canada and the U.S. There is a significant research gap on the topic in Latin America and the Caribbean.
综合有关旨在改善原住民获得卫生服务机会的干预措施有效性的证据。
回顾截至2015年7月发表的系统评价,仅选择并分析美洲地区的研究。文献检索涵盖MEDLINE、Lilacs、SciELO、EMBASE、DARE、HTA、Cochrane图书馆以及各组织网站。两名独立评审员选择研究并分析其方法学质量。对结果进行叙述性总结。
22篇综述符合纳入标准。所有入选研究均在加拿大和美利坚合众国开展。大多数干预措施具有预防性,旨在克服地理障碍、增加有效措施的使用、开发人力资源以及提高人们寻求医疗服务的技能或意愿。主题包括妊娠、心血管危险因素、糖尿病、药物滥用、儿童发育、癌症、心理健康、口腔健康和伤害。一些干预措施在中等或高质量研究中显示出有效性:预防抑郁症的教育策略、预防儿童龋齿的干预措施以及促进使用儿童安全座椅的多成分项目。总体而言,慢性非传染性疾病的结果为阴性或不一致。
确实存在一些有可能对美洲原住民获得卫生服务产生积极影响的干预措施,但现有研究仅限于加拿大和美国。拉丁美洲和加勒比地区在该主题上存在重大研究空白。