aLaboratory of Neuroscience (LIM-27), Department and Institute of Psychiatry, Faculty of Medicine, University of São Paulo bUNESP - Universidade Estadual Paulista, Biosciences Institute, Campus of Rio Claro, SP, Brazil.
Curr Opin Psychiatry. 2017 Mar;30(2):151-158. doi: 10.1097/YCO.0000000000000309.
The present article addresses intriguing questions related to the clinical intervention in distinct neuropsychiatric syndromes of patients with dementia.
We reviewed 154 articles published between 2015 and 2016 targeting psychopharmacological and nonpharmacological interventions, and safety-tolerability concerns. We selected 115 articles addressing the purpose of this study. Of these, 33 were chosen because they were dedicated to subtopics: agitation (42), depression (33), apathy (18), sleep disorders/anxiety (8), and psychosis (4). Clinical studies using both pharmacological (70) and nonpharmacological (37) interventions were considered; others were included for theoretical support. Regarding the methodological design, we found double-blind RCTs (17), single-blinded RCTs (4), open-label studies (18), case reports (5), cross-sectional or cohort studies (25), epidemiological papers (2), and expert reviews (44). This observation raises concerns about the overall methodological adequacy of a substantial proportion of studies in this field, which limits the potential of generalization of the findings. Finally, 18 studies were designed to determine safety-tolerability issues of psychotropic medications (6 were discussed).
Effective and well tolerated treatment of neuropsychiatric syndromes in dementia remains a critically unsolved challenge. We understand that this is an extremely important area of research, and critically required to guide clinical decisions in geriatric neuropsychiatry.
本文探讨了在痴呆患者的不同神经精神综合征的临床干预方面的一些有趣问题。
我们复习了 2015 年至 2016 年期间发表的 154 篇针对精神药理学和非药理学干预以及安全性耐受性问题的文章。我们选择了 115 篇旨在解决本研究目的的文章。其中 33 篇文章是因为它们专注于以下子主题:激越(42 篇)、抑郁(33 篇)、淡漠(18 篇)、睡眠障碍/焦虑(8 篇)和精神病(4 篇)。考虑了使用药理学(70 篇)和非药理学(37 篇)干预的临床研究;其他文章则为理论支持而被纳入。关于方法学设计,我们发现双盲 RCT(17 篇)、单盲 RCT(4 篇)、开放标签研究(18 篇)、病例报告(5 篇)、横断面或队列研究(25 篇)、流行病学论文(2 篇)和专家评论(44 篇)。这一观察结果引起了人们对该领域大量研究总体方法学适当性的关注,这限制了研究结果的推广潜力。最后,有 18 项研究旨在确定精神药物的安全性耐受性问题(其中 6 项进行了讨论)。
有效地治疗痴呆患者的神经精神综合征且具有良好的耐受性仍然是一个极具挑战性的难题。我们明白这是一个极其重要的研究领域,对指导老年神经精神病学的临床决策至关重要。