Gourie-Devi Mandaville, Gupta Reema, Sharma Vibha, Pardasani Vibhor, Maheshwari Siddharth
Department of Neurology, Institute of Human Behaviour and Allied Sciences, New Delhi, India.
Department of Clinical Psychology, Institute of Human Behaviour and Allied Sciences, New Delhi; Department of Psychology, University of Delhi, India.
Neurol India. 2017 Jan-Feb;65(1):46-51. doi: 10.4103/0028-3886.198177.
In amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), death wish is expressed in a varying proportion of patients in different countries. In this first study from India, influence of belief system of religion/spirituality and attitude towards death, widely prevalent in the country, in decision making, was evaluated.
Twenty ALS patients were assessed using 'Wish-to-Die Questionnaire' (WDQ) developed to reflect seven domains, namely religion/spirituality, belief in karma, meaning of life, hope, family support, financial support and death wish. Functional impairment, depression, hopelessness and suicidal ideation were assessed by ALS Functional Rating Scale, Beck's Depression Inventory, Beck Hopelessness Scale and The Scale of Suicidal Ideation, respectively.
On WDQ, all the 20 patients had belief in religion/spirituality, had hope and family support. Nineteen patients (95%) believed in karma, 16 (80%) still found life meaningful and 15 (75%) had financial support. Six patients (30%) had mild to moderate depression; hopelessness was present in 6 (30%) and suicidal ideation was present in one (5%). The 5 (25%) patients who expressed death wish did not significantly differ from others in 6 domains (religion/spirituality, belief in karma, meaning of life, hope, family support, financial support) of WDQ. The main reason in 3 patients who expressed death wish was lack of financial support. The fourth patient could not find meaning of life after the onset of illness, and the fifth wished to end his life since he had satisfactorily fulfilled all his responsibilities.
Smaller proportion of patients of ALS expressed death wish in India compared to the Western countries. This may be attributed to belief in religion/spirituality and karma, having meaning of life and family support. As this is the first report from India, useful information may be obtained if similar studies are done on a larger sample.
在肌萎缩侧索硬化症(ALS)中,不同国家有不同比例的患者表达出求死意愿。在印度的这项首次研究中,评估了该国广泛存在的宗教/精神信仰体系以及对死亡的态度在决策过程中的影响。
使用“求死问卷”(WDQ)对20例ALS患者进行评估,该问卷旨在反映七个领域,即宗教/精神信仰、因果报应信仰、生命意义、希望、家庭支持、经济支持和求死意愿。分别通过ALS功能评定量表、贝克抑郁量表、贝克绝望量表和自杀意念量表评估功能损害、抑郁、绝望和自杀意念。
在WDQ上,所有20例患者都有宗教/精神信仰,有希望和家庭支持。19例患者(95%)相信因果报应,16例(80%)仍然认为生活有意义,15例(75%)有经济支持。6例患者(30%)有轻度至中度抑郁;6例(30%)有绝望情绪,1例(5%)有自杀意念。表达求死意愿的5例(25%)患者在WDQ的6个领域(宗教/精神信仰、因果报应信仰、生命意义、希望、家庭支持、经济支持)与其他患者无显著差异。表达求死意愿的3例患者的主要原因是缺乏经济支持。第四例患者在患病后找不到生活的意义,第五例患者希望结束生命是因为他已圆满履行了所有责任。
与西方国家相比,印度ALS患者中表达求死意愿的比例较小。这可能归因于宗教/精神信仰和因果报应信仰、生活有意义以及家庭支持。由于这是印度的首份报告,如果对更大样本进行类似研究,可能会获得有用信息。