Departments of 1 Otorhinolaryngology and.
Department of Biomedical Statistics and Informatics, Mayo Clinic, Rochester, Minnesota.
J Neurosurg. 2017 Nov;127(5):992-999. doi: 10.3171/2016.9.JNS16515. Epub 2017 Jan 13.
OBJECTIVE The aim of this study was to evaluate the incidence, presentation, and treatment outcomes of trigeminal nerve-mediated symptoms secondary to large vestibular schwannomas (VSs) with trigeminal nerve contact. Specifically, the symptomatic results of pain, paresthesias, and numbness after microsurgical resection or stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) were examined. METHODS The authors conducted a retrospective review of a database for concomitant diagnosis of trigeminal neuralgia (TN) or trigeminal neuropathy and VS between 1994 and 2014 at a tertiary academic center. All patients with VS with TN or neuropathy were included, with the exception of those patients with neurofibromatosis Type 2 and patients who elected observation. Patient demographic data, symptom evolution, and treatment outcomes were collected. Population data were summarized, and outcome comparisons between microsurgery and SRS were analyzed at last follow-up. RESULTS Sixty (2.2%) of 2771 total patients who had large VSs and either TN or neuropathy symptoms met inclusion criteria. The average age of trigeminal symptom onset was 53.6 years (range 24-79 years), the average age at VS diagnosis was 54.4 years (range 25-79 years), and the average follow-up for the microsurgery and SRS groups was 30 and 59 months, respectively (range 3-132 months). Of these patients, 50 (83%) had facial numbness, 16 (27%) had TN pain, and 13 (22%) had paresthesias (i.e., burning or tingling). Subsequently, 50 (83%) patients underwent resection and 10 (17%) patients received SRS. Treatment of VS with SRS did not improve trigeminal symptoms in any patient. This included 2 subjects with unimproved facial numbness and 4 patients with worsened numbness. Similarly, SRS worsened TN pain and paresthesias in 5 patients and failed to improve pain in 2 additional patients. The Barrow Neurological Institute neuralgia and hypesthesia scale scores were significantly worse for patients undergoing SRS compared with microsurgery. Resection alleviated facial numbness in 22 (50%) patients, paresthesias in 5 (42%) patients, and TN in 7 (70%) patients. In several patients, surgery was not successful in relieving facial numbness, which failed to improve in 17 (39%) cases and became worse in 5 (11%) cases. Also, surgery did not change the intensity of facial paresthesias or neuralgia in 6 (50%) and 3 (25%) patients, respectively. Microsurgery exacerbated facial paresthesias in 1 (8%) patient but, notably, did not aggravate TN in any patient. CONCLUSIONS Overall, resection of large VSs provided improved outcomes for patients with concomitant TN, facial paresthesia, and numbness compared with SRS. However, caution should be used when counseling surgical candidates because a number of patients did not experience improvement. This was especially true in patients with preoperative facial numbness and paresthesias, who frequently reported that these symptoms were unchanged following surgery.
目的 本研究旨在评估与大型前庭神经鞘瘤(VS)接触相关的三叉神经介导症状的发生率、表现和治疗结果。具体来说,检查了显微切除或立体定向放射外科(SRS)后疼痛、感觉异常和麻木的症状结果。
方法 作者对 1994 年至 2014 年在一家三级学术中心同时诊断为三叉神经痛(TN)或三叉神经病变和 VS 的数据库进行了回顾性研究。所有伴有 TN 或神经病变的 VS 患者均包括在内,但不包括 2 型神经纤维瘤病患者和选择观察的患者。收集患者的人口统计学数据、症状演变和治疗结果。总结人群数据,并在最后一次随访时分析显微手术和 SRS 之间的结果比较。
结果 在 2771 例大型 VS 患者中,有 60 例(2.2%)同时伴有 TN 或神经病变症状,符合纳入标准。三叉神经症状发作的平均年龄为 53.6 岁(24-79 岁),VS 诊断的平均年龄为 54.4 岁(25-79 岁),显微手术和 SRS 组的平均随访时间分别为 30 个月和 59 个月(3-132 个月)。这些患者中,50 例(83%)有面部麻木,16 例(27%)有 TN 疼痛,13 例(22%)有感觉异常(即烧灼感或刺痛感)。随后,50 例(83%)患者接受了切除术,10 例(17%)患者接受了 SRS。SRS 治疗 VS 并不能改善任何患者的三叉神经症状。这包括 2 例面部麻木无改善,4 例面部麻木恶化。同样,SRS 恶化了 5 例 TN 疼痛和感觉异常,并使 2 例额外患者的疼痛恶化。与显微手术相比,SRS 患者的巴罗神经研究所神经痛和感觉减退量表评分明显更差。切除术缓解了 22 例(50%)患者的面部麻木,缓解了 5 例(42%)患者的感觉异常,缓解了 7 例(70%)患者的 TN。在一些患者中,手术未能成功缓解面部麻木,17 例(39%)患者麻木无改善,5 例(11%)患者麻木恶化。此外,手术对面部感觉异常或神经痛的强度在 6 例(50%)和 3 例(25%)患者中均无变化。显微手术使 1 例(8%)患者的面部感觉异常恶化,但值得注意的是,没有任何患者的 TN 加重。
结论 总体而言,与 SRS 相比,大型 VS 的切除为伴有 TN、面部感觉异常和麻木的患者提供了更好的治疗结果。然而,在为手术候选者提供咨询时应谨慎,因为许多患者没有体验到改善。对于术前有面部麻木和感觉异常的患者来说尤其如此,他们经常报告手术后这些症状没有改变。