Caro-Aguilar Ivette, Indrawati Lani, Kaufhold Robin M, Gaunt Christine, Zhang Yuhua, Nawrocki Denise K, Giovarelli Cecilia, Winters Michael A, Smith William J, Heinrichs Jon, Skinner Julie M
Department of Infectious Diseases/Vaccines, MRL (West Point, PA), Merck & Co., Inc., Kenilworth, NJ, United States.
Non-clinical Statistics, MRL (West Point, PA), Merck & Co., Inc., Kenilworth, NJ, United States.
Vaccine. 2017 Feb 7;35(6):865-872. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2016.12.055. Epub 2017 Jan 10.
Pneumococcal disease continues to be a medical need even with very effective vaccines on the market. Globally, there are extensive research efforts to improve serotype coverage with novel vaccines; therefore, conducting preclinical studies in different animal models becomes essential. The work presented herein focuses on evaluating a 15-valent pneumococcal conjugate vaccine (PCV15) in mice. Initially we evaluated several doses of PCV15 in Balb/c mice. The optimal vaccine dose was determined to be 0.4μg per pneumococcal polysaccharide (PS) (0.8μg of 6B) for subsequent studies. This PS dose was chosen for PCV evaluation in mice based on antibody levels determined by multiplexed electrochemiluminescent (ECL) assays, T-cell responses following in vitro stimulation with CRM197 peptides and protection from pneumococcal challenge. We then selected four mouse strains for evaluation: Balb/c, C3H/HeN, CD1 and Swiss Webster (SW), immunized with PCV15 by either intraperitoneal (IP) or intramuscular (IM) routes. We assessed IgG responses by ECL assays and functional antibody activity by multiplexed opsonophagocytic assays (MOPA). Every mouse strain evaluated responded to all 15 serotypes contained in the vaccine. Mice tended to have lower responses to serotypes 6B, 23F and 33F. The IP route of immunization resulted in higher antibody titers for most serotypes in Balb/c, C3H and SW. CD1 mice tended to respond similarly for most serotypes, regardless of route of immunization. Similar trends were observed with the four mouse strains when evaluating functional antibody activity. Given the differences in antibody responses based on mouse strain and route of immunization, it is critical to evaluate pneumococcal vaccines in multiple animal models to determine the optimal formulation before moving to clinical trials.
即使市场上已有非常有效的疫苗,肺炎球菌疾病仍然是一项医学需求。在全球范围内,人们正在进行广泛的研究,以通过新型疫苗提高血清型覆盖率;因此,在不同动物模型中开展临床前研究变得至关重要。本文介绍的工作重点是在小鼠中评估一种15价肺炎球菌结合疫苗(PCV15)。最初,我们在Balb/c小鼠中评估了几种剂量的PCV15。后续研究确定的最佳疫苗剂量为每微克肺炎球菌多糖(PS)0.4μg(6B为0.8μg)。基于多重电化学发光(ECL)测定法确定的抗体水平、用CRM197肽体外刺激后的T细胞反应以及对肺炎球菌攻击的保护作用,选择了该PS剂量用于小鼠中的PCV评估。然后,我们选择了四种小鼠品系进行评估:Balb/c、C3H/HeN、CD1和瑞士韦伯斯特(SW),通过腹腔内(IP)或肌肉内(IM)途径用PCV15免疫。我们通过ECL测定法评估IgG反应,并通过多重调理吞噬测定法(MOPA)评估功能性抗体活性。评估的每个小鼠品系对疫苗中包含的所有15种血清型都有反应。小鼠对血清型6B、23F和33F的反应往往较低。在Balb/c、C3H和SW中,IP免疫途径导致大多数血清型的抗体滴度更高。对于大多数血清型,CD1小鼠无论免疫途径如何,反应往往相似。在评估功能性抗体活性时,四种小鼠品系也观察到了类似趋势。鉴于基于小鼠品系和免疫途径的抗体反应存在差异,在进入临床试验之前,在多个动物模型中评估肺炎球菌疫苗以确定最佳配方至关重要。