Štouračová A, Šprláková-Puková A, Čižmář I, Procházková J, Janoušová E, Vališ P
Radiologická klinika, Fakultní nemocnice Brno, Lékařská fakulta Masarykovy univerzity, Brno.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2016;83(5):327-331.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Scapholunate dissociation is a clinically most frequently diagnosed form of carpal instability. The aim of this study was to compare high resolution MRI using a microscopic coil with direct MRI arthrography in patients with suspected scapholunate ligament lesions and compare the results with arthroscopy findings and Geissler's arthroscopy classification. MATERIAL AND METHODS A prospective study was carried out in 47 patients (average age, 30.7 years) with clinical symptoms of wrist instability from 2013 to 2014. The patients were examined with the MR device Philips Achieva 1.5T using a microscopic coil and subsequently by direct MR arthrography. The results of examination were evaluated independently by two groups of physicians using a modified arthroscopic classification. The results were verified arthroscopically. For evaluation, an adjusted Geissler's classification was used. The study was approved by the Multicentre Ethics Committee of the Faculty of Medicine in Brno and informed consent was obtained from each patient. RESULTS A total of The MRI examination was evaluated and included in the study in 44 patients (three were excluded for the presence of motion artefacts). Only 20 patients underwent arthroscopy. Examination with a microscopic coil correctly classified 14 of them; an accuracy of 70 % (95 % CI: 45.7 % - 88.1 %) and p = 0.021. Direct MR arthrography correctly classified 16 of 20 injured ligaments, i.e., an accuracy of 80 % (95 % CI: 56.3 % - 94.3 %) and p = 0.002. DISCUSSION Currently, the diagnosis of pathological changes in the wrist is made by routine MRI especially when there is the possibility of using sequences with high spatial resolution. Even though we achieved poorer results by native examination using these techniques, when they were compared with the results of direct MR arthrography, they were still better than those reported in the recent literature. CONCLUSION The optimal method for an examination algorithm of scapholunate ligament lesions is direct MR arthrography. In our study correct findings of direct MR arthrography using Geissler's classification were shown in 80 % of the patients. Key words: scapholunate ligament, scapholunate ligament lesion, direct MR arthrography, microscopic coil, Geissler's classification.
研究目的
舟月骨分离是临床上最常诊断出的腕关节不稳形式。本研究的目的是比较使用显微线圈的高分辨率MRI与直接MRI关节造影在疑似舟月韧带损伤患者中的应用,并将结果与关节镜检查结果及盖斯勒关节镜分类进行比较。
材料与方法
2013年至2014年,对47例有腕关节不稳临床症状的患者(平均年龄30.7岁)进行了一项前瞻性研究。患者使用飞利浦Achieva 1.5T MR设备,采用显微线圈进行检查,随后进行直接MRI关节造影。两组医生使用改良的关节镜分类法独立评估检查结果。结果通过关节镜检查进行验证。评估时采用了调整后的盖斯勒分类法。本研究经布尔诺医学院多中心伦理委员会批准,并获得了每位患者的知情同意。
结果
共有44例患者的MRI检查得到评估并纳入研究(3例因存在运动伪影被排除)。仅20例患者接受了关节镜检查。使用显微线圈检查正确分类了其中14例;准确率为70%(95%可信区间:45.7% - 88.1%),p = 0.021。直接MRI关节造影正确分类了20条损伤韧带中的16条,即准确率为80%(95%可信区间:56.3% - 94.3%),p = 0.002。
讨论
目前,腕关节病理改变的诊断通过常规MRI进行,尤其是在有可能使用高空间分辨率序列时。尽管我们使用这些技术进行原始检查的结果较差,但与直接MRI关节造影的结果相比,仍优于近期文献报道的结果。
结论
舟月韧带损伤检查算法的最佳方法是直接MRI关节造影。在我们的研究中,使用盖斯勒分类法,直接MRI关节造影的正确结果在80%的患者中得到显示。
舟月韧带,舟月韧带损伤,直接MRI关节造影,显微线圈,盖斯勒分类法