Schiff Gordon D, Volk Lynn A, Volodarskaya Mayya, Williams Deborah H, Walsh Lake, Myers Sara G, Bates David W, Rozenblum Ronen
Division of General Internal Medicine and Primary Care, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
Center for Patient Safety Research and Practice, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Boston, MA, USA.
J Am Med Inform Assoc. 2017 Mar 1;24(2):281-287. doi: 10.1093/jamia/ocw171.
The study objective was to evaluate the accuracy, validity, and clinical usefulness of medication error alerts generated by an alerting system using outlier detection screening.
Five years of clinical data were extracted from an electronic health record system for 747 985 patients who had at least one visit during 2012-2013 at practices affiliated with 2 academic medical centers. Data were screened using the system to detect outliers suggestive of potential medication errors. A sample of 300 charts was selected for review from the 15 693 alerts generated. A coding system was developed and codes assigned based on chart review to reflect the accuracy, validity, and clinical value of the alerts.
Three-quarters of the chart-reviewed alerts generated by the screening system were found to be valid in which potential medication errors were identified. Of these valid alerts, the majority (75.0%) were found to be clinically useful in flagging potential medication errors or issues.
A clinical decision support (CDS) system that used a probabilistic, machine-learning approach based on statistically derived outliers to detect medication errors generated potentially useful alerts with a modest rate of false positives. The performance of such a surveillance and alerting system is critically dependent on the quality and completeness of the underlying data.
The screening system was able to generate alerts that might otherwise be missed with existing CDS systems and did so with a reasonably high degree of alert usefulness when subjected to review of patients' clinical contexts and details.
本研究的目的是评估使用异常值检测筛选的警报系统生成的用药错误警报的准确性、有效性和临床实用性。
从电子健康记录系统中提取了5年的临床数据,涉及2012 - 2013年期间在2家学术医疗中心附属机构就诊至少一次的747985名患者。使用该系统对数据进行筛选,以检测提示潜在用药错误的异常值。从生成的15693条警报中选取300份病历进行审查。开发了一个编码系统,并根据病历审查进行编码,以反映警报的准确性、有效性和临床价值。
筛查系统生成的经病历审查的警报中有四分之三被发现是有效的,其中识别出了潜在的用药错误。在这些有效的警报中,大多数(75.0%)被发现对标记潜在的用药错误或问题具有临床实用性。
一个临床决策支持(CDS)系统使用基于统计得出的异常值的概率性机器学习方法来检测用药错误,生成了具有适度误报率的潜在有用警报。这种监测和警报系统的性能严重依赖于基础数据的质量和完整性。
该筛查系统能够生成现有CDS系统可能遗漏的警报,并且在对患者的临床背景和细节进行审查时,警报的实用性相当高。