Bell Jennifer M, Shields Michael D, Watters Janet, Hamilton Alistair, Beringer Timothy, Elliott Mark, Quinlivan Rosaline, Tirupathi Sandya, Blackwood Bronagh
Centre for Experimental Medicine, School of Medicine, Dentistry and Biomedical Sciences, Queen's University Belfast, Room 02.041, 2nd Floor, Mulhouse, Grosvenor Road, Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK, BT12 6BJ.
GP Out of Hours Service, Belfast Health and Social Care Trust, Belfast, Northern Ireland, UK.
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2017 Jan 24;1(1):CD010899. doi: 10.1002/14651858.CD010899.pub2.
Corticosteroid treatment is considered the 'gold standard' for Duchenne muscular dystrophy (DMD); however, it is also known to induce osteoporosis and thus increase the risk of vertebral fragility fractures. Good practice in the care of those with DMD requires prevention of these adverse effects. Treatments to increase bone mineral density include bisphosphonates and vitamin D and calcium supplements, and in adolescents with pubertal delay, testosterone. Bone health management is an important part of lifelong care for patients with DMD.
To assess the effects of interventions to prevent or treat osteoporosis in children and adults with DMD taking long-term corticosteroids; to assess the effects of these interventions on the frequency of vertebral fragility fractures and long-bone fractures, and on quality of life; and to assess adverse events.
On 12 September 2016, we searched the Cochrane Neuromuscular Specialised Register, CENTRAL, MEDLINE, Embase, and CINAHL Plus to identify potentially eligible trials. We also searched the Web of Science ISI Proceedings (2001 to September 2016) and three clinical trials registries to identify unpublished studies and ongoing trials. We contacted correspondence authors of the included studies in the review to obtain information on unpublished studies or work in progress.
We considered for inclusion in the review randomised controlled trials (RCTs) and quasi-RCTs involving any bone health intervention for corticosteroid-induced osteoporosis and fragility fractures in children, adolescents, and adults with a confirmed diagnosis of DMD. The interventions might have included oral and intravenous bisphosphonates, vitamin D supplements, calcium supplements, dietary calcium, testosterone, and weight-bearing activity.
Two review authors independently assessed reports and selected potential studies for inclusion, following standard Cochrane methodology. We contacted study authors to obtain further information for clarification on published work, unpublished studies, and work in progress.
We identified 18 potential studies, of which two, currently reported only as abstracts, met the inclusion criteria for this review. Too little information was available for us to present full results or adequately assess risk of bias. The participants were children aged five to 15 years with DMD, ambulant and non-ambulant. The interventions were risedronate versus no treatment in one trial (13 participants) and whole-body vibration versus a placebo device in the second (21 participants). Both studies reported improved bone mineral density with the active treatments, with no improvement in the control groups, but the abstracts did not compare treatment and control conditions. All children tolerated whole-body vibration treatment. No study provided information on adverse events. Two studies are ongoing: one investigating whole-body vibration, the other investigating zoledronic acid.
AUTHORS' CONCLUSIONS: We know of no high-quality evidence from RCTs to guide use of treatments to prevent or treat corticosteroid-induced osteoporosis and reduce the risk of fragility fractures in children and adults with DMD; only limited results from two trials reported in abstracts were available. We await formal trial reports. Findings from two ongoing relevant studies and two trials, for which only abstracts are available, will be important in future updates of this review.
皮质类固醇治疗被认为是杜氏肌营养不良症(DMD)的“金标准”;然而,众所周知它会诱发骨质疏松症,从而增加椎体脆性骨折的风险。对DMD患者进行良好护理需要预防这些不良反应。增加骨密度的治疗方法包括双膦酸盐、维生素D和钙补充剂,对于青春期延迟的青少年,还包括睾酮。骨骼健康管理是DMD患者终身护理的重要组成部分。
评估对长期服用皮质类固醇的DMD儿童和成人预防或治疗骨质疏松症的干预措施的效果;评估这些干预措施对椎体脆性骨折和长骨骨折发生率以及生活质量的影响;并评估不良事件。
2016年9月12日,我们检索了Cochrane神经肌肉专业注册库、CENTRAL、MEDLINE、Embase和CINAHL Plus,以识别潜在符合条件的试验。我们还检索了科学网ISI会议录(2001年至2016年9月)和三个临床试验注册库,以识别未发表的研究和正在进行的试验。我们联系了综述中纳入研究的通讯作者,以获取未发表研究或正在进行的工作的信息。
我们考虑将随机对照试验(RCT)和半随机对照试验纳入综述,这些试验涉及对确诊为DMD的儿童、青少年和成人因皮质类固醇诱发的骨质疏松症和脆性骨折进行的任何骨骼健康干预。干预措施可能包括口服和静脉注射双膦酸盐、维生素D补充剂、钙补充剂、膳食钙、睾酮和负重活动。
两位综述作者按照Cochrane标准方法独立评估报告并选择潜在纳入研究。我们联系研究作者以获取更多信息,以澄清已发表的工作、未发表的研究和正在进行的工作。
我们识别出18项潜在研究,其中两项目前仅以摘要形式报道,符合本综述的纳入标准。可用信息太少,我们无法呈现完整结果或充分评估偏倚风险。参与者为5至15岁的DMD儿童,包括能行走和不能行走的。一项试验(13名参与者)的干预措施是利塞膦酸盐与不治疗对比,另一项试验(21名参与者)的干预措施是全身振动与安慰剂装置对比。两项研究均报告活性治疗组骨密度改善,对照组无改善,但摘要未比较治疗组和对照组情况。所有儿童均耐受全身振动治疗。没有研究提供不良事件信息。两项研究正在进行:一项研究全身振动,另一项研究唑来膦酸。
我们不知道来自随机对照试验的高质量证据可指导使用治疗方法来预防或治疗皮质类固醇诱发的骨质疏松症并降低DMD儿童和成人脆性骨折的风险;仅有两项试验以摘要形式报道的有限结果可用。我们等待正式的试验报告。两项正在进行的相关研究以及两项仅有摘要可用的试验结果,对本综述的未来更新将很重要。