Bucher Sophie, Maury Arnaud, Rosso Julie, de Chanaud Nicolas, Bloy Géraldine, Pendola-Luchel Isabelle, Delpech Raphaëlle, Paquet Sylvain, Falcoff Hector, Ringa Virginie, Rigal Laurent
INSERM, CESP Centre for Research in Epidemiology and Population Health, U1018, Gender, Sexual and Reproductive Health Team, University of Paris-Sud, Le Kremlin-Bicêtre, France,
General Practice Department, Paris-Sud Faculty of Medicine, University of Paris-Sud, Le Kremlin-Bicêtre, France.
Fam Pract. 2017 Feb;34(1):49-56. doi: 10.1093/fampra/cmw108. Epub 2016 Oct 17.
Prevention is an essential task in primary care. According to primary care physicians (PCPs),lack of time is one of the principal obstacles to its performance.
To assess the feasibility of prevention in terms of time by estimating the time necessary to perform all of the preventive care recommended, separately from the PCPs and patient's perspectives, and to compare them to the amount of time available.
A review of the literature identified the prevention procedures recommended in France, the duration of each procedure and its recommended frequency, as well as PCPs' consultation time. A hypothetical patient panel size of 1000 patients, representative of the French population, served as the basis for our calculations of the annual time necessary for prevention for a PCP. The prevention time from the patient's perspective was estimated from data collected from a previous study of a panel of 3556 patients.
For PCPs, the annual time necessary for all of the required preventive care was 250 hours, or 20% of their total patient time. For a patient, the annual time required for prevention during encounters with a PCP ranged from 9.7 to 26.4 minutes per year. The mean total encounter time was 75.9 minutes per year. Nearly 73% of patients had a prevention-to-care time ratio exceeding 15%.
Feasibility thus differs substantially between patients. These differences correspond especially to disparities in the annual care time used by each patient. Specific solutions should be developed according to the patients' utilization of care.
预防是初级保健中的一项重要任务。据初级保健医生(PCP)称,时间不足是开展预防工作的主要障碍之一。
从时间角度评估预防工作的可行性,分别从初级保健医生和患者的角度估算开展所有推荐的预防保健所需的时间,并将其与可用时间进行比较。
通过文献综述确定了法国推荐的预防程序、每个程序的持续时间及其推荐频率,以及初级保健医生的诊疗时间。以1000名患者的假设患者群体规模作为计算初级保健医生每年预防所需时间的基础,该群体具有法国人口代表性。从患者角度的预防时间是根据之前对3556名患者群体的研究收集的数据估算得出的。
对于初级保健医生而言,开展所有所需预防保健每年所需时间为250小时,占其总诊疗时间的20%。对于患者而言,每年与初级保健医生诊疗期间预防所需时间为每年9.7至26.4分钟。平均每次诊疗总时间为每年75.9分钟。近73%的患者预防与诊疗时间之比超过15%。
因此,患者之间的可行性差异很大。这些差异尤其对应于每位患者每年诊疗时间的差异。应根据患者的诊疗利用情况制定具体解决方案。