Ayre Colin, Hardy Maryann, Scally Andrew, Radcliffe Graham, Venkatesh Ram, Smith Jon, Guy Stephen
Faculty of Health Studies, University of Bradford, Bradford, UK
Department of Orthopaedics, Bradford Teaching Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Bradford, UK.
Emerg Med J. 2017 May;34(5):302-307. doi: 10.1136/emermed-2015-205610. Epub 2017 Jan 31.
To identify the injury history features reported by patients with anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries and determine whether history may be used to identify patients requiring follow-up appointments from acute trauma services.
Multisite cross-sectional service evaluation using a survey questionnaire design conducted in the UK. The four injury history features investigated were 'leg giving way at the time of injury', 'inability to continue activity immediately following injury', 'marked effusion' and 'pop (heard or felt) at the time of injury'(LIMP).
194 patients with ACL injury were identified, of which 165 (85.5%) attended an acute trauma service. Data on delay was available for 163 (98.8%) of these patients of which 120 (73.6%) had a follow-up appointment arranged. Patients who had a follow-up appointment arranged waited significantly less time for a correct diagnosis (geometric mean 29 vs 198 days; p<0.001) and to see a specialist consultant (geometric mean 61 vs 328 days; p<0.001). Using a referral threshold of any two of the four LIMP injury history features investigated, 95.8% of patients would have had a follow-up appointment arranged.
Findings support the value of questioning patients on specific injury history features in identifying patients who may have suffered ACL injury. Using a threshold of two or more of the four LIMP history features investigated would have reduced the percentage of patients inappropriately discharged by 22.2%. Evidence presented suggests that this would significantly reduce the time to diagnosis and specialist consultation minimising the chance of secondary complications.
确定前交叉韧带(ACL)损伤患者报告的损伤史特征,并确定损伤史是否可用于识别需要从急性创伤服务机构进行随访预约的患者。
在英国采用调查问卷设计进行多中心横断面服务评估。所调查的四个损伤史特征为“受伤时腿部发软”“受伤后无法立即继续活动”“明显积液”以及“受伤时听到或感觉到‘砰’的一声”(LIMP)。
共识别出194例ACL损伤患者,其中165例(85.5%)就诊于急性创伤服务机构。这些患者中有163例(98.8%)有关于延误的数据,其中120例(73.6%)安排了随访预约。安排了随访预约的患者等待正确诊断的时间(几何平均数为29天对198天;p<0.001)以及等待看专科顾问的时间(几何平均数为61天对328天;p<0.001)显著更短。使用所调查的四个LIMP损伤史特征中任意两个作为转诊阈值,95.8%的患者会被安排随访预约。
研究结果支持询问患者特定损伤史特征对于识别可能患有ACL损伤患者的价值。使用所调查的四个LIMP损伤史特征中的两个或更多作为阈值,可将不适当出院患者的比例降低22.2%。所提供的证据表明,这将显著缩短诊断和专科会诊时间,将继发性并发症的发生几率降至最低。