Bertelsen Claus Anders
Dan Med J. 2017 Feb;64(2).
Surgery is the most important factor for radical treatment of colon cancer, and the long-term prognosis can be improved by improving the surgical treatment without increased risk of perioperative mortality. Complete mesocolic excision (CME), in which more extensive lymph node (LN) dissection is performed, has been shown in single-centre studies with historical controls to be associated with better oncological outcome. However, better evidence is needed. The main purpose of this PhD thesis was to investigate whether CME could be implemented in a colorectal surgical department in Denmark, whether more extensive dissection could demonstrate LN metastases outside the mesocolon, and to demonstrate a possible association between CME and improved oncological results without increased risk of perioperative mortality. This thesis includes five articles. Two articles (IV and V) are based on the population of patients undergoing elective resection for colon cancer in the Capital Region from June 2008 to December 2013. Two articles (II and III) are based on data from the local colon database in Hillerød, and the last article (I) is a systematic review concerning the risk of metastases from colon cancer to the central LNs in the mesocolon. Article I found a risk of metastases in central LNs to be reported in 1-22% of the cases of right-sided colon cancers, and in up to 12% of the cases with sigmoid tumours. The populations included and methods used in the studies were very heterogeneous and no definitive conclusions can be drawn. It was shown in article II that the surgical quality, i.e. quality of the specimens assessed by the pathologists, improved with implementation of CME in Hillerød. The vascular tie was higher, and the implementation was not associated with an increased risk of perioperative mortality. Article III demonstrated a risk of LN metastases in the gastrocolic ligament along the stomach for tumours located in the transverse colon, in the ascending or descending colon close to or in the flexures. It occurred in 4% of all patients and 13% of the patients with LN metastases in mesocolon. Resection of these LNs seems advisable for these tumour locations. Article IV showed no association between increased perioperative mortality and CME (n = 529) when compared with non-CME (n = 1,701). The 30-day mortality was 4.2% after CME compared with 3.7% after non-CME (p = 0.605), and the 90-day mortalities were 6.2% and 4.9% (p = 0.219) respectively. Odds ratios for 30-day and 90-day mortalities after CME were respectively 1.07 (95% confidence interval: 0.62-1.80) and 1.25 (0.77-1.94) in the multi-variable logistic regression analyses. Postoperative respiratory failure and need for vasopressors were significantly more frequent in the CME group and, besides CME itself, could be associated with the fewer laparoscopic resections and more severe preoperative comorbidity in the CME Group. Article V demonstrated an association between higher four-year disease-free survival for stage I-III tumours and CME (n = 364) when compared with non-CME (n = 1,031). Most notable was the difference for stage I and II cancers. The four-year disease-free survival for stage I was 100% in the CME group compared with 89.8% (83.1-96.6) in the non-CME group (p = 0.046). For stage II the disease-free survivals were 91.9% (87.2-96.6%) in the CME group and 77.9% (71.6-84.1%) in the non-CME group (p = 0.0033), and for stage III 73.5% (63.6-83.5) and 67.5% (61.8-73.2) (p = 0.13) respectively. In the multivariable Cox regression models, CME was a significant predictive factor for higher dis-ease-free four-year survival for stage I-III patients with hazard ratios (HR) for CME of 0.59 (0.42-0.83, p = 0.0025). For stage II the HR was 0.44 (0.23-0.86, p = 0.018) and for stage III 0.64 (0.42-1.00, p = 0.048).
手术是结肠癌根治性治疗的最重要因素,通过改进手术治疗可改善长期预后,且不增加围手术期死亡风险。完整结肠系膜切除术(CME)可进行更广泛的淋巴结(LN)清扫,单中心研究与历史对照研究表明,其与更好的肿瘤学结局相关。然而,仍需要更好的证据。本博士论文的主要目的是研究CME能否在丹麦的结直肠外科实施,更广泛的清扫能否发现结肠系膜外的LN转移,并证明CME与改善肿瘤学结果之间可能存在关联,且不增加围手术期死亡风险。本论文包括五篇文章。两篇文章(IV和V)基于2008年6月至2013年12月在首都地区接受择期结肠癌切除术的患者群体。两篇文章(II和III)基于希勒勒德当地结肠数据库的数据,最后一篇文章(I)是关于结肠癌转移至结肠系膜中央LN风险的系统评价。文章I发现,右侧结肠癌病例中有1%-22%报告存在中央LN转移风险,乙状结肠肿瘤病例中这一比例高达12%。研究纳入的人群和使用的方法非常多样,无法得出明确结论。文章II表明,在希勒勒德实施CME后,手术质量(即病理学家评估的标本质量)有所提高。血管结扎更高,且实施该手术与围手术期死亡风险增加无关。文章III表明,对于位于横结肠、升结肠或降结肠靠近或处于弯曲处的肿瘤,胃结肠韧带处的LN存在转移风险。在所有患者中,这一情况发生在4%的患者中,在结肠系膜LN转移患者中为13%。对于这些肿瘤位置,切除这些LN似乎是可取的。文章IV表明,与非CME组(n = 1701)相比,CME组(n = 529)围手术期死亡率增加与CME无关。CME后30天死亡率为4.2%,非CME后为3.7%(p = 0.605),90天死亡率分别为6.2%和4.9%(p = 0.219)。在多变量逻辑回归分析中,CME后30天和90天死亡率的比值比分别为1.07(95%置信区间:0.62 - 1.80)和1.25(0.77 - 1.94)。CME组术后呼吸衰竭和使用血管加压药的需求明显更频繁,除CME本身外,这可能与CME组腹腔镜切除术较少和术前合并症更严重有关。文章V表明,与非CME组(n = 1031)相比,I - III期肿瘤接受CME(n = 364)的患者四年无病生存率更高。I期和II期癌症的差异最为显著。CME组I期患者四年无病生存率为100%,非CME组为89.8%(83.1 - 96.6)(p = 0.046)。II期患者无病生存率在CME组为91.9%(87.2 - 96.6%),非CME组为77.9%(71.6 - 84.1%)(p = 0.0033),III期分别为73.5%(63.6 - 83.5)和67.5%(61.8 - 73.2)(p = 0.13)。在多变量Cox回归模型中,CME是I - III期患者四年无病生存率更高的显著预测因素,CME的风险比(HR)为0.59(0.42 - 0.83,p = 0.0025)。II期的HR为0.44(0.23 - 0.86,p = 0.018),III期为0.64(0.42 - 1.00,p = 0.048)。