Kim Gaeun, Ju Hyun Mi, Lee Sun Hee, Kim Hee-Soon, Kwon Jeong A, Seo Young Joon
*Department of Nursing, Keimyung University College, Daegu †Department of Otorhinolaryngology, Yonsei University Wonju College of Medicine, Wonju ‡Department of Nursing, Yonsei University, Seoul §Department of Nursing, National Cancer Control Institute, National Cancer Center, Goyang, South Korea.
Otol Neurotol. 2017 Apr;38(4):473-483. doi: 10.1097/MAO.0000000000001359.
Bone-anchored hearing aids (BAHAs) have been known to partially restore some of the functions lost in subjects with single-sided deafness (SSD). Our aims in this systemic review were to analyze the present capabilities of BAHAs in the context of SSD, and to evaluate the efficacy of BAHAs in improving speech recognition in noisy conditions, sound localization, and subjective outcomes.
A systematic search was undertaken until August 2015 by two independent reviewers, with disagreements resolved by consensus. Among 286 references, we analyzed 14 studies that used both subjective and objective indicators to assess the capabilities of a total of 296 patients in the unaided and aided situations.
Although there was "no benefit" of BAHA implantation for sound localization, BAHAs certainly improved subjects' speech discrimination in noisy circumstances. In the six studies that dealt with sound localization, no significant difference was found after the implantation. Twelve studies showed the benefits of BAHAs for speech discrimination in noise. Regarding subjective outcomes of using the prosthesis in patients with SSD (abbreviated profile of hearing aid benefit [APHAB] and the Glasgow hearing aid benefit profile [GHABP], etc.), we noticed an improvement in the quality of life.
This systematic review has indicated that BAHAs may successfully rehabilitate patients with SSD by alleviating the hearing handicap to a certain degree, which could improve patients' quality of life. This report has presented additional evidence of effective auditory rehabilitation for SSD and will be helpful to clinicians counseling patients regarding treatment options for SSD.
骨锚式助听器(BAHA)已知可部分恢复单侧耳聋(SSD)患者丧失的一些功能。我们进行这项系统评价的目的是分析在SSD背景下BAHA的现有能力,并评估BAHA在改善噪声环境下的言语识别、声音定位和主观结果方面的疗效。
由两名独立 reviewers 进行系统检索,直至2015年8月,分歧通过共识解决。在286篇参考文献中,我们分析了14项研究,这些研究使用主观和客观指标评估了总共296例患者在未佩戴和佩戴助听器情况下的能力。
尽管植入BAHA对声音定位“无益处”,但BAHA确实改善了受试者在嘈杂环境中的言语辨别能力。在六项涉及声音定位的研究中,植入后未发现显著差异。十二项研究表明BAHA对噪声中的言语辨别有益。关于SSD患者使用假体的主观结果(助听器益处简表[APHAB]和格拉斯哥助听器益处简表[GHABP]等),我们注意到生活质量有所改善。
这项系统评价表明,BAHA可能通过在一定程度上减轻听力障碍而成功使SSD患者康复,这可以提高患者的生活质量。本报告提供了SSD有效听觉康复的额外证据,将有助于临床医生为患者提供有关SSD治疗选择的咨询。