Joshi Madhav, Quinn Jason Michael
University of Notre Dame, Kroc Institute for Int'l Peace Studies, 100 Hesburgh Center, Notre Dame, IN 46556-5677, USA.
University of Notre Dame, Kroc Institute for Int'l Peace Studies, 100 Hesburgh Center, Notre Dame, IN 46556-5677, USA.
Soc Sci Res. 2017 Mar;63:227-241. doi: 10.1016/j.ssresearch.2016.09.003. Epub 2016 Sep 9.
Prior research on civilian targeting in civil war has focused on characteristics of either the government or rebel group that make them more or less likely to target civilians. However, no government or rebel group targets a population, but rather individuals within it. To date, no study has explored the issue of why particular civilians would be chosen by one actor versus the other. This study examines the divergent civilian-targeting strategies of governments and rebel groups. We argue that unique identification problems facing each political actor in civil war leads the parties to resort to social stereotypes based on data derived from known enemy subjects killed in combat. We specify and then test a model that accounts for time and space and the demographic characteristics of each victim utilizing a new dataset on the personal, political, and demographic characteristics of individual civilians targeted by the state and rebels in the civil war in Nepal (1996-2006). The findings demonstrate for the first time that governments (and rebels) tend to kill the same types of individuals in non-combat settings as they kill in combat exchanges, and the civilians targeted by each actor differ significantly in the extent that they share certain social traits.
先前关于内战中针对平民目标的研究主要集中在政府或反叛组织的特征上,这些特征使它们或多或少有可能将平民作为目标。然而,没有哪个政府或反叛组织会以整个人口为目标,而是针对其中的个体。迄今为止,尚无研究探讨为何某一方会选择特定平民而非另一方的问题。本研究考察了政府和反叛组织针对平民的不同策略。我们认为,内战中每个政治行为体面临的独特识别问题,导致各方诉诸基于在战斗中阵亡的已知敌方人员数据得出的社会刻板印象。我们详细阐述并检验了一个模型,该模型考虑了时间、空间以及每个受害者的人口特征,所使用的新数据集包含了尼泊尔内战(1996 - 2006年)期间被国家和反叛组织作为目标的平民个人、政治及人口特征。研究结果首次表明,政府(以及反叛组织)在非战斗环境中倾向于杀害与在战斗交火中相同类型的个体,而且每个行为体所针对的平民在共享某些社会特征的程度上存在显著差异。