Hinman R S, Nelligan R K, Bennell K L, Delany C
University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Victoria, Australia.
Arthritis Care Res (Hoboken). 2017 Dec;69(12):1834-1844. doi: 10.1002/acr.23218. Epub 2017 Nov 2.
To explore the experience of patients and physical therapists with Skype for exercise management of knee osteoarthritis (OA).
This was a qualitative study. The Donabedian model for quality assessment in health care (structure, process, and outcomes) informed semistructured individual interview questions. The study involved 12 purposively sampled patients with knee OA who received physical therapist-prescribed exercise over Skype, and all therapists (n = 8) who delivered the intervention in a clinical trial were interviewed about their experiences. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed. Two investigators undertook coding and analysis using a thematic approach.
Six themes arose from both patients and therapists. The themes were Structure: technology (easy to use, variable quality, set-up assistance helpful) and patient convenience (time efficient, flexible, increased access); Process: empowerment to self-manage (facilitated by home environment and therapists focusing on effective treatment) and positive therapeutic relationships (personal undivided attention from therapists, supportive friendly interactions); and Outcomes: satisfaction with care (satisfying, enjoyable, patients would recommend, therapists felt Skype more useful as adjunct to usual practice) and patient benefits (reduced pain, improved function, improved confidence and self-efficacy). A seventh theme arose from therapists regarding process: adjusting routine treatment (need to modify habits, discomfort without hands-on, supported by research environment).
Patients and physical therapists described mostly positive experiences using Skype as a service delivery model for physical therapist-supervised exercise management of moderate knee OA. Such a model is feasible and acceptable and has the potential to increase access to supervised exercise management for people with knee OA, either individually or in combination with traditional in-clinic visits.
探讨患者和物理治疗师使用Skype进行膝关节骨关节炎(OA)运动管理的体验。
这是一项定性研究。医疗保健质量评估的唐纳贝迪安模型(结构、过程和结果)为半结构化的个人访谈问题提供了依据。该研究纳入了12名经目的抽样选取的膝关节OA患者,他们通过Skype接受了物理治疗师规定的运动治疗,并且对在一项临床试验中提供干预的所有治疗师(n = 8)进行了访谈,了解他们的体验。访谈进行了录音和转录。两名研究人员采用主题分析法进行编码和分析。
患者和治疗师都出现了六个主题。这些主题是:结构:技术(易于使用、质量不一、设置协助有帮助)和患者便利性(省时、灵活、增加可及性);过程:自我管理的赋权(家庭环境和治疗师专注于有效治疗促进了这一点)和积极的治疗关系(治疗师给予个人全身心关注、支持性友好互动);结果:对护理的满意度(令人满意、愉快,患者会推荐,治疗师认为Skype作为常规治疗的辅助手段更有用)和患者获益(疼痛减轻、功能改善、信心和自我效能提高)。治疗师还提出了关于过程的第七个主题:调整常规治疗(需要改变习惯、没有亲自操作时的不适感,有研究环境的支持)。
患者和物理治疗师描述了使用Skype作为物理治疗师监督的中度膝关节OA运动管理服务提供模式的大多积极体验。这样的模式是可行且可接受的,并且有可能增加膝关节OA患者获得监督运动管理的机会,无论是单独使用还是与传统的门诊就诊相结合。