Maini Rishma, Hotchkiss David R, Borghi Josephine
London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, 15-17 Tavistock Place, London, WC1H 9SH, United Kingdom.
School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, Tulane University, 1440 Canal Street, New Orleans, LA, 70112, United States of America.
Hum Resour Health. 2017 Feb 20;15(1):17. doi: 10.1186/s12960-017-0185-4.
In the Democratic Republic of Congo (DRC), the state system to remunerate health workers is poorly functional, encouraging diversification of income sources and corruption. Given the central role that health workers play in health systems, policy-makers need to ensure health workers are remunerated in a way which best incentivises them to provide effective and good quality services. This study describes the different sources and quantities of income paid to primary care health workers in Equateur, Maniema, Kasai Occidental, Province Orientale and Kasai Oriental provinces. It also explores characteristics associated with the receipt of different sources of income.
Quantitative data on the income received by health workers were collected through baseline surveys. Descriptive statistics explored the demographic characteristics of health workers surveyed, and types and amounts of incomes received. A series of regression models were estimated to examine the health worker and facility-level determinants of receiving each income source and of levels received. Qualitative data collection was carried out in Kasai Occidental province to explore perceptions of each income source and reasons for receiving each.
Nurses made up the majority of workers in primary care. Only 31% received a government salary, while 75% reported compensation from user fees. Almost half of all nurses engaged in supplemental non-clinical activities. Receipt of government payments was associated with income from private practice and non-clinical activities. Male nurses were more likely to receive per diems, performance payments, and higher total remuneration compared to females. Contextual factors such as provincial location, presence of externally financed health programmes and local user fee policy also influenced the extent to which nurses received many income sources.
The receipt of government payments was unreliable and had implications for receipt of other income sources. A mixture of individual, facility and geographical factors were associated with the receipt of various income sources. Greater co-ordination is needed between partners involved in health worker remuneration to design more effective financial incentive packages, reduce the fragmentation of incomes and improve transparency in the payment of workers in the DRC.
在刚果民主共和国,卫生工作者薪酬支付的国家体系运转不佳,这助长了收入来源的多样化和腐败现象。鉴于卫生工作者在卫生系统中发挥的核心作用,政策制定者需要确保以最能激励他们提供有效且高质量服务的方式来支付薪酬。本研究描述了赤道省、马尼埃马省、西开赛省、东方省和东开赛省基层医疗保健工作者的不同收入来源和收入数量。同时还探讨了与不同收入来源获取相关的特征。
通过基线调查收集了关于卫生工作者收入的定量数据。描述性统计分析了接受调查的卫生工作者的人口统计学特征以及所获得收入的类型和金额。估计了一系列回归模型,以检验获得每种收入来源及其收入水平的卫生工作者和机构层面的决定因素。在西开赛省进行了定性数据收集,以探究对每种收入来源的看法以及获得每种收入的原因。
护士构成了基层医疗保健工作者的大多数。只有31%的人领取政府工资,而75%的人报告有来自用户费用的补偿。几乎一半的护士从事补充性非临床活动。获得政府支付与私人执业收入及非临床活动收入相关。与女性相比,男性护士更有可能获得每日津贴、绩效工资以及更高的总薪酬。省级位置、外部资助卫生项目的存在以及当地用户费用政策等背景因素也影响了护士获得多种收入来源的程度。
政府支付不可靠,且对其他收入来源的获取有影响。个人、机构和地理因素的综合作用与各种收入来源的获取相关。参与卫生工作者薪酬支付的各方之间需要加强协调,以设计更有效的财务激励方案,减少收入分散,并提高刚果民主共和国卫生工作者薪酬支付的透明度。