Pope Karl, So Yuen T, Crane Julian, Bates Michael N
Division of Environmental Health Sciences, School of Public Health, University of California, Berkeley, CA, USA.
Department of Neurology, Stanford University, Palo Alto, CA 94305, USA.
Neurotoxicology. 2017 May;60:10-15. doi: 10.1016/j.neuro.2017.02.006. Epub 2017 Feb 14.
The mechanism of toxicity of hydrogen sulfide (HS) gas is thought mainly to operate through effects on the nervous system. The gas has high acute toxicity, but whether chronic exposure causes effects, including peripheral neuropathy, is yet unclear. The city of Rotorua, New Zealand, sits on an active geothermal field and the population has some of the highest measured ambient HS exposures. A previous study in Rotorua provided evidence that HS is associated with peripheral neuropathy. Using clinical methods, the present study sought to investigate and possibly confirm this association in the Rotorua population. The study population comprised 1635 adult residents of Rotorua, aged 18-65. Collected data relevant to the peripheral neuropathy investigation included symptoms, ankle stretch reflex, vibration sensitivity, as measured by the timed-tuning fork test and a Bio-Thesiometer (Bio-Medical Instrument Co., Ohio), and light touch sensitivity measured by monofilaments. An exposure metric, estimating time-weighted HS exposure across the last 30 years was used. Principal components analysis was used to combine data across the various indicators of possible peripheral neuropathy. The main data analysis used linear regression to examine associations between the peripheral nerve function indicators and HS exposure. None of the peripheral nerve function indicators were associated with HS exposure, providing no evidence that HS exposure at levels found in Rotorua is a cause of peripheral neuropathy. The earlier association between HS exposure and peripheral neuropathy diagnoses may be attributable to the ecological study design used. The possibility that HS exposure misclassification could account for the lack of association found cannot be entirely excluded.
硫化氢(HS)气体的毒性机制主要被认为是通过对神经系统的作用来发挥的。这种气体具有高急性毒性,但长期接触是否会产生影响,包括周围神经病变,目前尚不清楚。新西兰的罗托鲁瓦市位于一个活跃的地热区,当地居民所测得的环境HS暴露水平在世界上处于高位。此前在罗托鲁瓦进行的一项研究提供了证据,表明HS与周围神经病变有关。本研究采用临床方法,试图在罗托鲁瓦人群中调查并可能证实这种关联。研究人群包括1635名年龄在18至65岁之间的罗托鲁瓦成年居民。收集的与周围神经病变调查相关的数据包括症状、踝部伸展反射、振动敏感性(通过定时音叉试验和生物感觉阈值测量仪(生物医学仪器公司,俄亥俄州)测量)以及通过单丝测量的轻触觉敏感性。使用了一种暴露指标,估算过去30年的时间加权HS暴露量。主成分分析用于整合各种可能的周围神经病变指标的数据。主要数据分析采用线性回归来检验周围神经功能指标与HS暴露之间的关联。没有一个周围神经功能指标与HS暴露相关,这表明没有证据表明罗托鲁瓦所发现的HS暴露水平是周围神经病变的一个病因。早期HS暴露与周围神经病变诊断之间的关联可能归因于所采用的生态学研究设计。不能完全排除HS暴露错误分类可能导致未发现关联的可能性。