Manikas Vicky, Babl Franz E, Hearps Stephen, Dooley Julian, Anderson Vicki
1 Department of Child Neuropsychology, Murdoch Childrens Research Institute , Melbourne, Australia .
3 Department of Paediatrics, University of Melbourne , Melbourne, Australia .
J Neurotrauma. 2017 Jun 1;34(11):1932-1938. doi: 10.1089/neu.2016.4762. Epub 2017 Mar 21.
Recovery from concussion in childhood is poorly understood, despite its importance in decisions regarding return to normal activity. Resolution of post-concussive symptoms (PCS) is widely employed as a marker of recovery in clinical practice; however, it is unclear whether subtle impairments persist only to re-emerge in the context of increased physical or cognitive demands. This study aimed to examine the effect of strenuous exercise on clinical symptom report and neurocognition in children and adolescents after PCS resolution after concussion. We recruited children and adolescents with concussion (n = 30) on presentation to an Emergency Department (ED). At Day 2 and Day 10 post-self-reported symptom resolution, participants completed a strenuous exercise protocol, and pre- and post-exercise assessment of PCS and neurocognition. Results demonstrated an overall reduction in PCS from Day 2 to Day 10 post-symptom resolution, with no evidence of symptom increase after strenuous exercise at either time point. Neurocognitive performance was linked to task complexity: on less cognitively demanding tasks, processing speed was slower post-exercise and, unexpectedly, slower on Day 10 than Day 2, while for more demanding tasks (new learning), Day 2 exercise resulted in faster responses, but Day 10 processing speed post-exercise was slower. In summary, we found the expected recovery pattern for PCS, regardless of exercise, while for neurocognition, recovery was dependent on the degree of cognitive demand, and there was an unexpected reduction in performance from Day 2 to Day 10. Findings provide some suggestion that premature return to normal activities (e.g., school) may slow neurocognitive recovery.
尽管脑震荡恢复情况对于决定儿童恢复正常活动至关重要,但人们对其了解甚少。在临床实践中,脑震荡后症状(PCS)的消退被广泛用作恢复的标志;然而,尚不清楚轻微损伤是否仅在身体或认知需求增加的情况下才会再次出现。本研究旨在探讨剧烈运动对脑震荡后PCS消退的儿童和青少年临床症状报告及神经认知的影响。我们招募了因脑震荡就诊于急诊科的儿童和青少年(n = 30)。在自我报告症状消退后的第2天和第10天,参与者完成了一项剧烈运动方案,并在运动前后对PCS和神经认知进行了评估。结果显示,从症状消退后的第2天到第10天,PCS总体有所减轻,在两个时间点进行剧烈运动后均无症状增加的迹象。神经认知表现与任务复杂性相关:在认知要求较低的任务中,运动后处理速度较慢,出乎意料的是,第10天比第2天更慢,而对于要求更高的任务(新学习),第2天运动后反应更快,但第10天运动后处理速度较慢。总之,我们发现无论是否运动,PCS都呈现出预期的恢复模式,而对于神经认知,恢复取决于认知需求的程度,并且从第2天到第10天表现出现意外下降。研究结果表明,过早恢复正常活动(如上学)可能会减缓神经认知恢复。