Wood Christine V, Campbell Patricia B, McGee Richard
Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL.
Cambell-Kibler Associates, Inc., Groton, MA.
J Women Minor Sci Eng. 2016;22(2):159-181. doi: 10.1615/JWomenMinorScienEng.2016014000.
This paper analyzes perspectives on academic careers among 60 beginning PhD students in the biomedical sciences. It presents seven perspectives on academic careers articulated by the students in the sample and explains the way that race/ethnicity, gender, and students' family education backgrounds are tied to those perspectives. The findings show that traditionally underrepresented students find the academic career path less navigable than students from well-represented groups. Among underrepresented students, even those from higher family education backgrounds, experiences related to race/ethnicity and gender often inform perceptions of the academic career even before they start their graduate research training. As the composition of the graduate population changes to include more women and underrepresented racial and ethnic minority men, it is important to note that not all graduate students enter with the same perspectives and views of the academic career and that there are meaningful differences in perspectives across demographic lines. Graduate programs can play a critical role in providing information and support for graduate students as they navigate their career choices, particularly at the earliest stages of training. By becoming sensitive to students' perspectives on career options, and understanding how differences in perspectives arise, mentors and others can align advising strategies with the experiences and views of students.
本文分析了60名生物医学科学领域的初入博士生对学术生涯的看法。它呈现了样本中学生们阐述的关于学术生涯的七种观点,并解释了种族/民族、性别和学生的家庭教育背景与这些观点的关联方式。研究结果表明,传统上代表性不足的学生认为学术职业道路比来自代表性充分群体的学生更难驾驭。在代表性不足的学生中,即使是那些来自较高家庭教育背景的学生,与种族/民族和性别相关的经历往往在他们开始研究生研究训练之前就影响了他们对学术生涯的认知。随着研究生群体的构成发生变化,包括更多女性以及代表性不足的种族和少数民族男性,需要注意的是,并非所有研究生进入时对学术生涯都有相同的看法和观点,而且不同人口群体之间的观点存在显著差异。在研究生选择职业道路时,尤其是在训练的最初阶段,研究生项目可以在为他们提供信息和支持方面发挥关键作用。通过对学生关于职业选择的观点保持敏感,并理解观点差异是如何产生的,导师和其他人可以使建议策略与学生的经历和观点保持一致。