Clayton Russell B, Leshner Glenn, Tomko Rachel L, Trull Timothy J, Piasecki Thomas M
a School of Communication , Florida State University , Tallahassee , Florida , USA.
b Gaylord College of Journalism and Mass Communication , University of Oklahoma , Norman , Oklahoma , USA.
J Health Commun. 2017 Mar;22(3):254-261. doi: 10.1080/10810730.2016.1268222. Epub 2017 Feb 19.
There is a lack of research examining whether smoking cues in anti-tobacco advertisements elicit cravings, or whether this effect is moderated by countervailing message attributes, such as disgusting images. Furthermore, no research has examined how these types of messages influence nicotine withdrawn smokers' cognitive processing and associated behavioral intentions. At a laboratory session, participants (N = 50 nicotine-deprived adults) were tested for cognitive processing and recognition memory of 12 anti-tobacco advertisements varying in depictions of smoking cues and disgust content. Self-report smoking urges and intentions to quit smoking were measured after each message. The results from this experiment indicated that smoking cue messages activated appetitive/approach motivation resulting in enhanced attention and memory, but increased craving and reduced quit intentions. Disgust messages also enhanced attention and memory, but activated aversive/avoid motivation resulting in reduced craving and increased quit intentions. The combination of smoking cues and disgust content resulted in moderate amounts of craving and quit intentions, but also led to heart rate acceleration (indicating defensive processing) and poorer recognition of message content. These data suggest that in order to counter nicotine-deprived smokers' craving and prolong abstinence, anti-tobacco messages should omit smoking cues but include disgust. Theoretical implications are also discussed.
目前缺乏研究来检验反烟草广告中的吸烟提示是否会引发烟瘾,或者这种效应是否会受到诸如恶心图像等抵消性信息属性的调节。此外,尚无研究考察这类信息如何影响尼古丁戒断吸烟者的认知加工及相关行为意图。在一次实验室环节中,对参与者(N = 50名尼古丁剥夺成年人)进行了测试,考察他们对12则反烟草广告的认知加工和识别记忆,这些广告在吸烟提示和恶心内容的描绘上各有不同。在每条信息展示后测量自我报告的吸烟冲动和戒烟意图。该实验结果表明,吸烟提示信息激活了欲求/趋近动机,导致注意力和记忆力增强,但增加了烟瘾并降低了戒烟意图。恶心信息也增强了注意力和记忆力,但激活了厌恶/回避动机,导致烟瘾降低和戒烟意图增加。吸烟提示与恶心内容的组合导致了适量的烟瘾和戒烟意图,但也导致心率加快(表明防御性加工)以及对信息内容的识别较差。这些数据表明,为了对抗尼古丁剥夺吸烟者的烟瘾并延长戒烟期,反烟草信息应省略吸烟提示但包含恶心内容。同时也讨论了理论意义。