Goettems Marília Leão, Zborowski Eduardo Jung, Costa Francine Dos Santos, Costa Vanessa Polina Pereira, Torriani Dione Dias
Postgradute Program in Dentistry, Federal University of Pelotas, Pelotas, Brazil.
School of Dentistry, Federal University of Pelotas, Pelotas, Brazil.
Acad Pediatr. 2017 Mar;17(2):110-119. doi: 10.1016/j.acap.2016.08.012.
Nonpharmacologic interventions may be used to reduce fear and anxiety during dental treatment.
To systematically review trials on the effect of nonpharmacologic interventions in behavior, anxiety, and pain perception in children undergoing dental treatment.
Medline, Scopus, Web of Science and CINAHL, Google Scholar, and studies' reference lists.
Studies performed with children and adolescents that evaluated the effect of interventions on children's behavior, anxiety, and pain perception during dental treatment were included.
Independent quality assessment of the studies was carried out following the classification categories present on the Cochrane Handbook for Development of Systematic Reviews of Intervention.
Twenty-two articles, reporting 21 studies, were selected. Most studies tested distraction techniques. Eight studies presented bias and results were not considered. The remaining 13 studies had control groups with inactive controls, and 4 also included a variation of the intervention. Of the 4 studies assessing behavior, 3 found difference between intervention and control. Anxiety was evaluated by 10 studies: 4 found differences between intervention and control and 2 found differences between interventions. Five studies investigated pain perception: 3 found difference comparing active versus inactive interventions. In 1 of the 3, variations in the intervention decreased pain perception.
More research is needed to know whether the techniques are effective for improving behavior and reducing children's pain and distress during dental treatment. However, the majority of the techniques improved child's behavior, anxiety, and pain perception.
非药物干预可用于减轻牙科治疗期间的恐惧和焦虑。
系统评价关于非药物干预对接受牙科治疗儿童的行为、焦虑和疼痛感知影响的试验。
医学期刊数据库(Medline)、Scopus数据库、科学引文索引(Web of Science)和护理学与健康领域数据库(CINAHL)、谷歌学术以及各研究的参考文献列表。
纳入对儿童和青少年进行的研究,这些研究评估了干预措施对牙科治疗期间儿童行为、焦虑和疼痛感知的影响。
按照《Cochrane干预性系统评价手册》中的分类类别对研究进行独立的质量评估。
共筛选出22篇文章,报道了21项研究。大多数研究测试了分散注意力技术。8项研究存在偏倚,其结果未被纳入考虑。其余13项研究设有非活性对照的对照组,4项研究还纳入了干预措施的变体。在评估行为的4项研究中,3项发现干预组与对照组存在差异。10项研究评估了焦虑:4项发现干预组与对照组存在差异,2项发现不同干预措施之间存在差异。5项研究调查了疼痛感知:3项发现主动干预与非主动干预之间存在差异。在这3项研究中的1项里,干预措施的变体降低了疼痛感知。
需要更多研究来确定这些技术在改善接受牙科治疗儿童的行为、减轻疼痛和痛苦方面是否有效。然而,大多数技术改善了儿童的行为、焦虑和疼痛感知。