Lee Eun-Jeong, Jung Chul-Ho
Research Headquarter, Korea Brain Research Institute, Daegu, Republic of Korea.
Department of Psychiatry, Dongsan Medical Center, Keimyung University, 56 Dalseong-Ro, Daegu, Republic of Korea.
Asian J Psychiatr. 2017 Feb;25:16-21. doi: 10.1016/j.ajp.2016.09.002. Epub 2016 Sep 30.
Neurofeedback (NF) has been identified as a "possibly efficacious" treatment in current evidence-based reviews; therefore, more research is needed to determine its effects. The current study examined the potential additive effect of NF for children diagnosed with ADHD beginning a medication trial first. Thirty-six children (6-12 years) with a DSM-IV-TR diagnosis of ADHD were randomly assigned to an NF with medication (NF condition) or a medication only condition. Children in the NF group attended 20 twice-weekly sessions. Outcome measures included individual cognitive performance scores (ADS, K-WISC-III), ADHD rating scores completed by their parents (ARS, CRS) and brainwave indices of left and right hemispheres before and after NF treatment. Significant additive treatment effect in any of the symptom variables was found and a reduction of theta waves in both the right and left hemispheres was recorded in NF condition participants. However our randomized controlled study could not demonstrate superior effects of combined NF on intelligent functioning compared to the medication treatment only. This study suggested any possible evidence of positive and additive treatment effects of NF on brainwaves and ADHD symptomatology.
在当前基于证据的综述中,神经反馈(NF)已被确定为一种“可能有效的”治疗方法;因此,需要更多研究来确定其效果。本研究首先考察了NF对开始药物试验的多动症患儿的潜在附加效应。36名诊断为多动症的儿童(6至12岁)被随机分配到接受NF联合药物治疗组(NF组)或仅接受药物治疗组。NF组的儿童参加了20次每周两次的治疗课程。结果测量包括个体认知表现分数(ADS、K-WISC-III)、父母完成的多动症评分分数(ARS、CRS)以及NF治疗前后左右半球的脑电波指标。在任何症状变量中均未发现显著的附加治疗效果,且NF组参与者左右半球的θ波均有所减少。然而,我们的随机对照研究未能证明与仅药物治疗相比,联合NF对智力功能有更优效果。本研究提示了NF对脑电波和多动症症状学有积极附加治疗效果的任何可能证据。