Stewart Amanda M, Cook Mark S, Esparza Mary C, Slayden Ov D, Alperin Marianna
Reproductive Medicine, University of California, La Jolla, San Diego, CA, USA.
Integrative Biology and Physiology, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, USA.
Int Urogynecol J. 2017 Oct;28(10):1527-1535. doi: 10.1007/s00192-017-3303-x. Epub 2017 Mar 11.
Animal models are essential to further our understanding of the independent and combined function of human pelvic floor muscles (PFMs), as direct studies in women are limited. To assure suitability of the rhesus macaque (RM), we compared RM and human PFM architecture, the strongest predictor of muscle function. We hypothesized that relative to other models, RM best resembles human PFM.
Major architectural parameters of cadaveric human coccygeus, iliococcygeus, and pubovisceralis (pubococcygeus + puborectalis) and corresponding RM coccygeus, iliocaudalis, and pubovisceralis (pubovaginalis + pubocaudalis) were compared using 1- and 2-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) with post hoc testing. Architectural difference index (ADI), a combined measure of functionally relevant structural parameters predictive of length-tension, force-generation, and excursional muscle properties was used to compare PFMs across RM, rabbit, rat, and mouse.
RM and human PFMs were similar with respect to architecture. However, the magnitude of similarity varied between individual muscles, with the architecture of the most distinct RM PFM, iliocaudalis, being well suited for quadrupedal locomotion. Except for the pubovaginalis, RM PFMs inserted onto caudal vertebrae, analogous to all tailed animals. Comparison of the PFM complex architecture across species revealed the lowest, thus closest to human, ADI for RM (1.9), followed by rat (2.0), mouse (2.6), and rabbit (4.7).
Overall, RM provides the closest architectural representation of human PFM complex among species examined; however, differences between individual PFMs should be taken into consideration. As RM is closely followed by rat with respect to PFM similarity with humans, this less-sentient and substantially cheaper model is a good alternative for PFM studies.
由于对女性的直接研究有限,动物模型对于增进我们对人类盆底肌肉(PFM)独立及联合功能的理解至关重要。为确保恒河猴(RM)的适用性,我们比较了RM与人类PFM的结构,结构是肌肉功能的最强预测指标。我们假设相对于其他模型,RM与人类PFM最为相似。
使用单因素和双因素方差分析(ANOVA)及事后检验,比较了尸体人类尾骨肌、髂尾肌和耻骨内脏肌(耻骨尾骨肌+耻骨直肠肌)以及相应RM尾骨肌、髂尾肌和耻骨内脏肌(耻骨阴道肌+耻骨尾骨肌)的主要结构参数。使用结构差异指数(ADI),这是一种对预测长度-张力、力量产生和伸展性肌肉特性的功能相关结构参数的综合测量,来比较RM、兔子、大鼠和小鼠的PFM。
RM和人类PFM在结构方面相似。然而,个体肌肉之间的相似程度有所不同,RM中最独特的PFM即髂尾肌的结构非常适合四足运动。除耻骨阴道肌外,RM的PFM附着于尾椎,这与所有有尾动物类似。跨物种比较PFM复合体结构发现,RM的ADI最低,因此最接近人类(1.9),其次是大鼠(2.0)、小鼠(2.6)和兔子(4.7)。
总体而言,在研究的物种中,RM对人类PFM复合体的结构呈现最为接近;然而,应考虑个体PFM之间的差异。由于在PFM与人类的相似性方面,RM紧随大鼠之后,这种较少感知且成本低得多的模型是PFM研究的良好替代选择。