Onwubalili J K
Division of Communicable Diseases, MRC Clinical Research Centre, Harrow, Middlesex, U.K.
Afr J Med Med Sci. 1987 Sep;16(3):123-32.
Seven of twenty-eight (25%) patients with untreated tuberculosis had skin induration of less than 6 mm to one tuberculin unit (TU), and 3 (11%) to 10 TU PPD. Among twenty-four patients with lung disease, there were no detectable differences in radiological extent of disease between reactors and non-reactors to low-dose tuberculin. However, non-reactors were significantly more malnourished (P less than 0.02), excreted more bacilli (P less than 0.02) and took longer for sputum sterilization during chemotherapy (P less than 0.01). Early skin reactions (6-8 h) occurred in fourteen of twenty-four (58%) patients, but in none of twenty-four matched healthy controls (P less than 0.0001); the proportions giving delayed (48-72 h) reactions were similar. Although the patients had larger delayed reactions as a group (P = 0.04), this would not have been of value in making the diagnosis. Repeat tuberculin testing of subjects had a booster effect, but did not induce hypersensitivity in initially healthy non-reactors. All nutritional abnoalities observed in the patients, except arm muscle circumference and serum albumin, reverted to normal during chemotherapy, concomitant with clinical improvement and an increase in dermal reactivity to tuberculin. Antigen overload may lead to both skin anergy and undernutrition. The accelerated tuberculin skin reaction could offer a practical and specific, although not particularly sensitive, method of aiding the diagnosis of active tuberculosis.
28例未经治疗的结核病患者中,7例(25%)对1个结核菌素单位(TU)的皮肤硬结小于6mm,3例(11%)对10TU的结核菌素纯蛋白衍生物(PPD)皮肤硬结小于6mm。在24例肺部疾病患者中,对低剂量结核菌素反应者和无反应者之间疾病的放射学范围没有可检测到的差异。然而,无反应者营养不良更为明显(P<0.02),排出的杆菌更多(P<0.02),化疗期间痰菌转阴所需时间更长(P<0.01)。24例患者中有14例(58%)出现早期皮肤反应(6 - 8小时),但24例匹配的健康对照者均未出现(P<0.0001);出现延迟(48 - 72小时)反应的比例相似。尽管患者作为一个群体的延迟反应更大(P = 0.04),但这对诊断并无价值。对受试者进行重复结核菌素检测有增强作用,但不会在最初健康的无反应者中诱发超敏反应。患者中观察到的所有营养异常情况,除了上臂肌肉周长和血清白蛋白外,在化疗期间均恢复正常,同时伴有临床改善和对结核菌素的皮肤反应性增加。抗原过载可能导致皮肤无反应性和营养不良。加速结核菌素皮肤反应虽然不是特别敏感,但可为协助诊断活动性结核病提供一种实用且特异的方法。