Mortlock Anna-Marie, Puzzo Ignazio, Taylor Sophie, Kumari Veena, Young Susan, Sengupta Samrat, Das Mrigendra
Broadmoor Hospital, West London Mental Health Trust, Crowthorne, UK.
Kings College London, London, UK.
BMC Psychiatry. 2017 Mar 16;17(1):83. doi: 10.1186/s12888-017-1236-z.
The majority of research studies on medical student attitudes toward psychiatry focus on influencing factors and the medical school experience. This study evaluates the effectiveness of a one-day visit to a high secure forensic psychiatric unit on medical students' attitudes towards psychiatry and also assesses career intentions and the factors influencing these.
Change in attitudes and career intention were measured by administering a questionnaire, which included the 30-item Attitudes Toward Psychiatry (ATP-30) survey, at the start (time 1) and end (time 2) of the one-day visit. Qualitative data on factors influencing career choice was also gathered.
Evaluation of 284 responses revealed a significant increase in positive attitude towards psychiatry from time 1 to time 2 in the sample as a whole. The most influential factor on consideration of psychiatry as a career across all groups was the medical school clinical placement. For those that tended away from choosing psychiatry as a career, patient prognosis was important.
Poor recruitment in psychiatry in the UK is already established which will doubtless be compounded by controversies surrounding the proposed new junior doctors' contract. Now more than ever, the need to inspire and motivate those at medical school encountering psychiatry is crucial. Our findings add to the body of evidence that the medical school clinical attachment is fundamental in shaping attitudes. However, these results also show that a well-planned visit to a specialised psychiatric unit outside of traditional placements can have a significant impact on students' attitudes toward psychiatry and mental illness in general. There is limited literature in the UK on enrichment activities within the psychiatry medical school curriculum. We propose that developing opportunities for enrichment activities within psychiatry could increase the scope of how we engage students in this fascinating field of medicine.
大多数关于医学生对精神病学态度的研究都集中在影响因素和医学院学习经历上。本研究评估了对高度戒备的法医精神病科进行为期一天的参观对医学生对精神病学态度的有效性,同时还评估了职业意向以及影响这些意向的因素。
通过在为期一天参观的开始(时间1)和结束(时间2)时发放一份问卷来测量态度和职业意向的变化,问卷包括30项《对精神病学的态度》(ATP - 30)调查。还收集了关于影响职业选择因素的定性数据。
对284份回复的评估显示,总体样本中从时间1到时间2对精神病学的积极态度有显著增加。在所有群体中,将精神病学作为职业考虑的最有影响力因素是医学院的临床实习。对于那些倾向于不选择精神病学作为职业的人来说,患者预后很重要。
英国精神病学领域招聘情况不佳的现状已经存在,而围绕拟议的新初级医生合同的争议无疑会使其更加恶化。现在比以往任何时候都更需要激励和激发医学院中接触精神病学的学生。我们的研究结果进一步证明,医学院的临床实习在塑造态度方面至关重要。然而,这些结果也表明,在传统实习之外精心策划的对专业精神病科的参观,可能会对学生对精神病学和一般精神疾病的态度产生重大影响。在英国,关于精神病学医学院课程中丰富活动的文献有限。我们建议,在精神病学领域开发丰富活动的机会,可以扩大我们让学生参与这一迷人医学领域的方式。