Warnke Ingeborg, Gamma Alex, Buadze Maria, Schleifer Roman, Canela Carlos, Strebel Bernd, Tényi Tamás, Rössler Wulf, Rüsch Nicolas, Liebrenz Michael
Department of Forensic Psychiatry, Institute of Forensic Medicine, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Department of Psychosomatic Medicine, Protestant Hospital Hagen-Haspe, Hagen, Germany.
Front Psychiatry. 2018 Mar 12;9:49. doi: 10.3389/fpsyt.2018.00049. eCollection 2018.
Psychiatry as a medical discipline is becoming increasingly important due to the high and increasing worldwide burden associated with mental disorders. Surprisingly, however, there is a lack of young academics choosing psychiatry as a career. Previous evidence on medical students' perspectives is abundant but has methodological shortcomings. Therefore, by attempting to avoid previous shortcomings, we aimed to contribute to a better understanding of the predictors of the following three outcome variables: current medical students' attitudes toward psychiatry, interest in psychiatry, and estimated likelihood of working in psychiatry. The sample consisted of = 1,356 medical students at 45 medical schools in Germany and Austria as well as regions of Switzerland and Hungary with a German language curriculum. We used snowball sampling Facebook with a link to an online questionnaire as recruitment procedure. Snowball sampling is based on referrals made among people. This questionnaire included a German version of the Attitudes Toward Psychiatry Scale (ATP-30-G) and further variables related to outcomes and potential predictors in terms of sociodemography (e.g., gender) or medical training (e.g., curriculum-related experience with psychiatry). Data were analyzed by linear mixed models and further regression models. On average, students had a positive attitude to and high general interest in, but low professional preference for, psychiatry. A neutral attitude to psychiatry was partly related to the discipline itself, psychiatrists, or psychiatric patients. Female gender and previous experience with psychiatry, particularly curriculum-related and personal experience, were important predictors of all outcomes. Students in the first years of medical training were more interested in pursuing psychiatry as a career. Furthermore, the country of the medical school was related to the outcomes. However, statistical models explained only a small proportion of variance. The findings indicate that particularly curriculum-related experience is important for determining attitudes toward psychiatry, interest in the subject and self-predicted professional career choice. We therefore encourage the provision of opportunities for clinical experience by psychiatrists. However, further predictor variables need to be considered in future studies.
由于全球精神障碍负担居高不下且呈上升趋势,精神病学作为一门医学学科正变得越来越重要。然而,令人惊讶的是,选择精神病学作为职业的年轻学者却很匮乏。此前关于医学生观点的证据很多,但存在方法上的缺陷。因此,为了避免此前的缺陷,我们旨在更好地理解以下三个结果变量的预测因素:当前医学生对精神病学的态度、对精神病学的兴趣以及从事精神病学工作的估计可能性。样本包括德国、奥地利以及瑞士和匈牙利部分使用德语课程地区的45所医学院的1356名医学生。我们采用雪球抽样法,通过脸书发布在线问卷链接来招募参与者。雪球抽样基于人与人之间的推荐。该问卷包括德文版的《精神病学态度量表》(ATP - 30 - G)以及与结果和潜在预测因素相关的其他变量,涉及社会人口统计学(如性别)或医学培训(如与精神病学课程相关的经历)。数据采用线性混合模型和进一步的回归模型进行分析。平均而言,学生对精神病学持积极态度且普遍兴趣较高,但对其专业偏好较低。对精神病学的中立态度部分与该学科本身、精神科医生或精神科患者有关。女性性别以及之前与精神病学的经历,特别是与课程相关的经历和个人经历,是所有结果的重要预测因素。医学培训初期的学生对从事精神病学职业更感兴趣。此外,医学院所在国家与结果有关。然而,统计模型仅解释了一小部分方差。研究结果表明,特别是与课程相关的经历对于确定对精神病学的态度、对该学科的兴趣以及自我预测的职业选择非常重要。因此,我们鼓励精神科医生提供临床经验机会。然而,未来的研究需要考虑更多的预测变量。