Fox J F
Institute of Arctic Biology, University of Alaska, 99701, Fairbanks, AK, USA.
Oecologia. 1985 Sep;67(2):244-249. doi: 10.1007/BF00384293.
Recent theories predict the evolution of dioecy among higher plants, in association with certain pollination and fruit dispersal traits. However, reported associations of dioecy with pollination, dispersal and growth form traits have not distinguished the effects of each trait separately, controlling for the others. Because these traits are associated among themselves, existing analyses may involve spurious or indirect correlations. This paper reports the incidence of dioecy in a subarctic and an arctic flora, and analyzes the occurrence of dioecy among vascular plants classified jointly by growth form, floral (pollination) syndrome, and fruit (dispersal) syndrome. Dioecism is no more frequent in the arctic flora as a whole, but its incidence increases northward among woody plants. This increase is associated with an increase in the proportion of woody species having small, inconspicuous flowers, and not with the syndrome of fleshy or animal dispersed fruits. Within the floras of Alaska, California, and the Northeastern US, dioecy is markedly more frequent among woody plants and among plants having small, inconspicuous flowers, and that is the only strong statistical association of dioecy for the species of these floras. When genera and families are analyzed similarly, dioecy is also associated significantly with dispersal syndrome. Thus, among angiosperms, evidence currently does not support either an uniquely strong or exclusive association of dioecy with dispersal traits, as it does for gymnosperms (Givnish 1980). It is extremely desirable to analyze the occurrence of dioecy among taxa classified jointly by all relevant ecological traits, rather than analyzing marginal distributions.
近期理论预测,高等植物中雌雄异株现象的演化与某些授粉及果实传播特性相关。然而,已报道的雌雄异株与授粉、传播及生长形式特性之间的关联,并未在控制其他特性的情况下,分别区分每种特性的影响。由于这些特性相互关联,现有分析可能涉及虚假或间接的相关性。本文报告了亚北极和北极植物区系中雌雄异株的发生率,并分析了按生长形式、花(授粉)综合征和果实(传播)综合征共同分类的维管植物中雌雄异株的出现情况。总体而言,北极植物区系中雌雄异株现象并不更常见,但其发生率在木本植物中向北增加。这种增加与具有小而不显眼花朵的木本物种比例增加有关,而与肉质或动物传播果实的综合征无关。在阿拉斯加、加利福尼亚和美国东北部的植物区系中,雌雄异株在木本植物和具有小而不显眼花朵的植物中明显更为常见,这是这些植物区系物种中雌雄异株唯一显著的统计关联。当对属和科进行类似分析时,雌雄异株也与传播综合征显著相关。因此,在被子植物中,目前的证据并不支持雌雄异株与传播特性存在独特的强关联或排他性关联,就像裸子植物那样(吉夫尼什,1980年)。极其有必要分析按所有相关生态特性共同分类的分类群中雌雄异株的出现情况,而不是分析边缘分布。