Department of Psychology, University of Waterloo.
J Appl Psychol. 2017 Jul;102(7):1109-1123. doi: 10.1037/apl0000210. Epub 2017 Mar 23.
Disturbances are factors outside of a person's control that influence goal progress. Although disturbances are typically included in theoretical accounts of goal pursuit, relatively little empirical research has explicitly considered the effects of disturbances on the goal-striving process. We address this gap in the literature by examining the effects that disturbances have on the emotional experience of goal pursuit. More importantly, we differentiate between distance disturbances (changes to the amount of progress made) and velocity disturbances (changes to the rate of progress made). We conducted 2 experiments (N = 62 and N = 134) in which participants completed work simulation tasks to earn a $5.00 reward. Partway through the experiment participants' progress was inhibited by either a distance disturbance or a velocity disturbance. Importantly, the distance and velocity disturbances were equated in terms of their influence on the likelihood of obtaining the cash prize. In both studies the introduction of a disturbance decreased enthusiasm and increased frustration. However, over time the effects of distance and velocity disturbances on enthusiasm and frustration diverged. Specifically, the velocity disturbance had a more enduring effect on these emotions, relative to the distance disturbance. Downstream, in Study 1 enthusiasm positively predicted goal commitment. In Study 2 enthusiasm positively predicted goal commitment, effort, and task performance. Likewise, in Study 2 frustration negatively predicted goal commitment and task performance. Therefore, relative to distance disturbances, velocity disturbances appear to be more disruptive to goal pursuit. We discuss theoretical implications and practical implications for managing employee motivation. (PsycINFO Database Record
干扰是影响目标进展的人无法控制的因素。尽管干扰通常包含在目标追求的理论解释中,但相对较少的实证研究明确考虑了干扰对目标努力过程的影响。我们通过研究干扰对目标追求的情绪体验的影响来解决文献中的这一差距。更重要的是,我们区分了距离干扰(进展量的变化)和速度干扰(进展率的变化)。我们进行了 2 项实验(N=62 和 N=134),参与者完成工作模拟任务以赚取 5 美元的奖励。在实验进行到一半时,参与者的进展受到距离干扰或速度干扰的抑制。重要的是,距离和速度干扰在获得现金奖励的可能性方面是等效的。在这两项研究中,干扰的引入降低了热情并增加了挫败感。然而,随着时间的推移,距离和速度干扰对热情和挫败感的影响出现了分歧。具体来说,速度干扰对这些情绪的影响更为持久,相对于距离干扰。在下游,在研究 1 中,热情积极地预测了目标承诺。在研究 2 中,热情积极地预测了目标承诺、努力和任务表现。同样,在研究 2 中,挫败感消极地预测了目标承诺和任务表现。因此,与距离干扰相比,速度干扰似乎对目标追求更具破坏性。我们讨论了管理员工动机的理论意义和实际意义。