Jung Kyoungsim, Jung Jinhwa, In Taesung, Kim Taehoon, Cho Hwi-Young
Department of Occupational Therapy, Semyung University, Jecheon, Republic of Korea.
Department of Physical Therapy, Gimcheon University, Gimcheon, Republic of Korea.
NeuroRehabilitation. 2017;40(3):315-323. doi: 10.3233/NRE-161419.
This study investigated the efficacy of Task-Related Training (TRT) Combined with Transcutaneous Electrical Nerve Stimulation (TENS) on the improvement of upper limb muscle activation in chronic stroke survivors with mild or moderate paresis.
A single-blind, randomized clinical trial was conducted with 46stroke survivors with chronic paresis. They were randomly allocated two groups: the TRT+TENS group (n = 23) and the TRT+ placebo TENS (TRT+PLBO) group (n = 23). The TRT+TENS group received 30 minutes of high-frequency TENS on wrist and elbow extensors, while the TRT+PLBO group received placebo TENS that was not real ES. Both groups did 30 minutes of TRT after TENS application. Intervention was given five days a week for four weeks. The primary outcomes of upper limb muscle activation were measured by integrated EMG (IEMG), a digital manual muscle tester for muscle strength, active range of motion (AROM) and Fugl-Meyer Assessment of the upper extremity (FMA-UE). The measurements were performed before and after the 4 weeks intervention period.
Both groups demonstrated significant improvements of outcomes in IEMG, AROM, muscle strength and FMA-UE during intervention period. When compared with the TRT+PLBO group, the TRT+TENS group showed significantly greater improvement in muscle activation (wrist extensors, P = 0.045; elbow extensors, P = 0.004), muscle strength (wrist extensors, P = 0.044; elbow extensors, P = 0.012), AROM (wrist extension, P = 0.042; elbow extensors, P = 0.040) and FMA-UE (total, P < 0.001; shoulder/elbow/forearm, P = 0.001; wrist, P = 0.002; coordination, P = 0.008) at the end of intervention.
Our findings indicate that TRT Combined with TENS can improve paretic muscle activity in upper limb paresis, highlighting the benefits of somatosensory stimulation from TENS.
本研究调查了任务相关训练(TRT)联合经皮电神经刺激(TENS)对改善轻度或中度麻痹的慢性卒中幸存者上肢肌肉激活的效果。
对46名患有慢性麻痹的卒中幸存者进行了一项单盲随机临床试验。他们被随机分为两组:TRT+TENS组(n = 23)和TRT+安慰剂TENS(TRT+PLBO)组(n = 23)。TRT+TENS组在手腕和肘部伸肌上接受30分钟的高频TENS,而TRT+PLBO组接受非真正电刺激的安慰剂TENS。两组在施加TENS后均进行30分钟的TRT。干预每周进行五天,共四周。通过积分肌电图(IEMG)、用于肌肉力量的数字手动肌力测试仪、主动关节活动度(AROM)和上肢Fugl-Meyer评估(FMA-UE)来测量上肢肌肉激活的主要结果。在4周干预期前后进行测量。
两组在干预期内IEMG、AROM、肌肉力量和FMA-UE的结果均有显著改善。与TRT+PLBO组相比,TRT+TENS组在干预结束时肌肉激活(手腕伸肌,P = 0.045;肘部伸肌,P = 0.004)、肌肉力量(手腕伸肌,P = 0.044;肘部伸肌,P = 0.012)、AROM(手腕伸展,P = 0.042;肘部伸肌,P = 0.040)和FMA-UE(总分,P < 0.001;肩部/肘部/前臂,P = 0.001;手腕,P = 0.002;协调性,P = 0.008)方面有显著更大的改善。
我们的研究结果表明,TRT联合TENS可以改善上肢麻痹中瘫痪肌肉的活动,突出了TENS体感刺激的益处。