Departments of Anatomy.
Sagol School of Neuroscience, Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv, Israel.
Pain Med. 2017 Sep 1;18(9):1715-1730. doi: 10.1093/pm/pnw349.
Previous studies on the sensitivity and reactivity to pain of individuals with intellectual disability (ID) are inconsistent. The inconsistency may result from the reliance on self-reports and facial expressions of pain that are subject to internal and external biases. The aim was therefore to evaluate the reactivity to pain of individuals with ID by recording pain-evoked potentials (EPs), here for the first time, and testing their association with behavioral pain indices.
Forty-one healthy adults, 16 with mild-moderate ID and 25 controls.
Subjects received series of phasic heat stimuli and rated their pain on self-report scales. Changes in facial expressions and in pain EPs were recorded and analyzed offline.
Pain self-reports, facial expressions, and the N2P2 amplitudes of the EPs exhibited stimulus-response relationship with stimulation intensity in both groups. The facial expressions and N2P2 amplitudes of individuals with ID were increased and N2P2 latency prolonged compared with controls. N2P2 amplitudes correlated with self-reports only in controls.
Individuals with ID are hypersensitive/reactive to pain, a finding bearing clinical implications. Although pain EPs may reflect a somewhat different aspect of pain than the behavioral indices do, there is evidence to support their use to record pain in noncommunicative individuals, pending further validation.
先前关于智力障碍(ID)个体对疼痛的敏感性和反应性的研究结果不一致。这种不一致可能是由于依赖于自我报告和疼痛的面部表情,而这些都受到内部和外部偏见的影响。因此,本研究旨在通过记录疼痛诱发电位(EPs)首次评估 ID 个体的疼痛反应性,并测试其与行为疼痛指数的相关性。
41 名健康成年人,16 名轻度至中度 ID 患者和 25 名对照组。
受试者接受了一系列的阶段性热刺激,并在自我报告量表上对疼痛进行了评分。记录和离线分析面部表情和疼痛 EPs 的变化。
在两组中,疼痛的自我报告、面部表情和 EPs 的 N2P2 振幅均表现出与刺激强度的刺激-反应关系。与对照组相比,ID 个体的面部表情和 N2P2 振幅增加,N2P2 潜伏期延长。仅在对照组中,N2P2 振幅与自我报告相关。
ID 个体对疼痛敏感/反应过度,这一发现具有临床意义。尽管疼痛 EPs 可能反映的疼痛方面与行为指数不同,但有证据支持将其用于记录非交流个体的疼痛,有待进一步验证。