Research Institute on Health Sciences (IUNICS), University of the Balearic Islands, Palma, Spain.
Pain. 2011 Apr;152(4):853-859. doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2010.12.037. Epub 2011 Feb 5.
Facial expression is one of the most relevant nonverbal behaviors in the communication of pain. However, little is known about brain processing of pain expressions in comparison with other affective facial expressions. The present experiment aimed to examine the effects of pain expression intensity on affective ratings and brain dynamics by recording electroencephalography (EEG) from 20 female healthy volunteers 18-24 years of age. Participants were asked to rate the affective characteristics of 144 stimuli depicting facial expressions of pain and anger with 3 level of intensities (high, mild, and low), as well as neutral faces. Results indicated that pain faces were judged as more unpleasant and arousing than anger and neutral faces for all intensity levels. EEG results further showed that facial expressions of pain elicited more enhanced amplitudes of the visual evoked potentials than anger and neutral faces in the latency between 350 and 550 milliseconds after stimulus onset; whereas anger faces elicited greater P200 amplitudes than pain and neutral faces. In addition, more increased theta activity in the latency of 200 to 400 milliseconds after stimulus onset was observed to high-intense as compared with low-intense facial expressions. These findings indicate that brain activity elicited by affective faces is modulated by the intensity of facial expressions and suggest the involvement of different brain mechanisms during the processing and recognition of facial expressions of pain and anger in healthy volunteers.
面部表情是疼痛交流中最相关的非言语行为之一。然而,与其他情感面部表情相比,人们对疼痛表情的大脑处理过程知之甚少。本实验旨在通过记录 20 名 18-24 岁女性健康志愿者的脑电图(EEG),研究疼痛表情强度对情感评分和大脑动力学的影响。要求参与者对 144 个刺激进行情感特征评分,这些刺激描绘了疼痛和愤怒的面部表情,以及中性面孔,其强度分为三级(高、中、低)。结果表明,与愤怒和中性面孔相比,所有强度水平的疼痛面孔都被判断为更不愉快和更令人兴奋。脑电图结果进一步表明,与愤怒和中性面孔相比,疼痛面部表情在刺激后 350 至 550 毫秒的潜伏期内引起了更增强的视觉诱发电位幅度;而愤怒面孔在刺激后 200 至 400 毫秒的潜伏期内引起了更大的 P200 幅度。此外,与低强度面部表情相比,高强度面部表情引起的潜伏期内θ活动增加更多。这些发现表明,大脑对情感面孔的活动受到面部表情强度的调节,并表明在健康志愿者对面部表情的处理和识别过程中,疼痛和愤怒的面部表情涉及不同的大脑机制。