Barth Johannes, Boutsiadis Achilleas, Narbona Pablo, Lädermann Alexandre, Arrigoni Paolo, Adams Christopher R, Burkhart Stephen S, Denard Patrick J
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Centre Osteoarticulaire des Cèdres, Grenoble, France.
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Centre Osteoarticulaire des Cèdres, Grenoble, France.
J Shoulder Elbow Surg. 2017 Jul;26(7):1121-1127. doi: 10.1016/j.jse.2017.01.026. Epub 2017 Mar 31.
The aim of this study was to find reliable anatomic landmarks of the normal acromioclavicular joint (ACJ) that could enable the precise evaluation of the horizontal displacement of the clavicle after dislocation. The hypothesis was that the anterior borders of the acromion and the clavicle are always aligned in intact ACJs.
In 30 cadaveric specimens, the anterior and posterior borders of the ACJ's articular facets and the most prominent anterior and posterior bony landmarks of the acromion and the clavicle were identified. The anterior and posterior overhang of the acromion and the clavicle was measured in relation to the borders of the articular facets. Therefore, the possible anterior and posterior alignment of the ACJ was evaluated.
Anteriorly, only 18 ACJs (60%) were aligned whereas 7 (24%) had major overhang of the acromion and 3 (10%) had major overhang of the clavicle. Similarly, 18 cases (60%) were posteriorly aligned, whereas 6 (20%) had major clavicular overhang and 4 (14%) had major overhang of the acromion. In 78% of these cases, the ACJ was aligned as well anteriorly as posteriorly (P < .001). Finally, the larger the width of the acromion (P = .032) or the clavicle (P = .049), the better the posterior joint alignment.
Our hypothesis was not verified. The acromion and clavicle are not perfectly aligned in a significant number of specimens with intact ACJs (40% of cases). The most reliable landmarks remain their articular facets.
本研究的目的是寻找正常肩锁关节(ACJ)可靠的解剖标志,以便能够精确评估脱位后锁骨的水平移位情况。假设是在完整的肩锁关节中肩峰和锁骨的前缘始终对齐。
在30具尸体标本中,确定了肩锁关节关节面的前后缘以及肩峰和锁骨最突出的前后骨性标志。测量了肩峰和锁骨相对于关节面边界的前后悬垂情况。因此,评估了肩锁关节可能的前后对齐情况。
在前方,只有18个肩锁关节(60%)是对齐的,而7个(24%)肩峰有较大悬垂,3个(10%)锁骨有较大悬垂。同样,18例(60%)在后方是对齐的,而6例(20%)锁骨有较大悬垂,4例(14%)肩峰有较大悬垂。在这些病例中,78%的肩锁关节前后方均对齐(P < 0.001)。最后,肩峰(P = 0.032)或锁骨(P = 0.049)越宽,关节后方对齐越好。
我们的假设未得到验证。在大量肩锁关节完整的标本中(40%的病例),肩峰和锁骨并未完美对齐。最可靠的标志仍然是它们的关节面。