Cunningham D, Bradley C J, Forrest G J, Hutcheon A W, Adams L, Sneddon M, Harding M, Kerr D J, Soukop M, Kaye S B
Department of Medical Oncology, Royal Infirmary, Glasgow, U.K.
Eur J Cancer Clin Oncol. 1988 Apr;24(4):685-9. doi: 10.1016/0277-5379(88)90300-8.
Eighty patients receiving their first course of chemotherapy with regimens containing cisplatin or cisplatin analogues entered this open crossover study comparing nabilone 2 mg and prochlorperazine 5 mg given orally every 12 h for four doses against metoclopramide 2 mg/kg loading dose intravenously (i.v.), then 3 mg/kg as an (i.v.) infusion over 8 h and dexamethasone 20 mg (i.v.) over 3-5 min at the time of chemotherapy. There was complete control of nausea and vomiting in 24 patients (32%) given metoclopramide and dexamethasone compared to 14 patients (19%) given nabilone and prochlorperazine. For the 70 patients who completed the crossover assessment of emesis on a linear analogue scale significantly favoured metoclopramide and dexamethasone (P = 0.02). However, there was no overall patient preference for the metoclopramide and dexamethasone combination (nabilone and prochlorperazine 31 vs. metoclopramide and dexamethasone 26; 13 no preference), because a significant proportion of the patients receiving the cisplatin analogue carboplatin preferred nabilone and prochlorperazine (16 vs. 5; 1 no preference; P = 0.013). For patients receiving cisplatin chemotherapy metoclopramide and dexamethasone remains the antiemetic of choice but for regimens containing carboplatin, nabilone and prochlorperazine is better tolerated and preferred by the patients.
80例接受含顺铂或顺铂类似物方案首次化疗的患者进入了这项开放交叉研究,该研究比较了每12小时口服2毫克纳布啡和5毫克丙氯拉嗪,共四剂,与静脉注射(i.v.)2毫克/千克负荷剂量的甲氧氯普胺,然后在8小时内以3毫克/千克静脉输注,以及在化疗时静脉注射(i.v.)20毫克地塞米松的效果。接受甲氧氯普胺和地塞米松治疗的24例患者(32%)恶心和呕吐得到完全控制,而接受纳布啡和丙氯拉嗪治疗的患者为14例(19%)。对于70例完成呕吐交叉评估的患者,在线性模拟量表上,甲氧氯普胺和地塞米松明显更受青睐(P = 0.02)。然而,总体上患者对甲氧氯普胺和地塞米松联合用药并无偏好(纳布啡和丙氯拉嗪组31例,甲氧氯普胺和地塞米松组26例;13例无偏好),因为接受顺铂类似物卡铂治疗的相当一部分患者更喜欢纳布啡和丙氯拉嗪(16例对5例;1例无偏好;P = 0.013)。对于接受顺铂化疗的患者,甲氧氯普胺和地塞米松仍是首选的止吐药,但对于含卡铂的方案,纳布啡和丙氯拉嗪耐受性更好,更受患者青睐。