Graham Sonia, Rogers Sarah
School of Social Sciences, The University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
Centre for Contemporary Chinese Studies, The University of Melbourne, Melbourne, Australia.
Environ Manage. 2017 Sep;60(3):396-408. doi: 10.1007/s00267-017-0859-7. Epub 2017 Apr 6.
For two decades researchers and policy makers have been arguing that community-based collective action is needed to effectively control weeds. Yet there has been little social research into the ways that collective weed control emerges at local scales. The aim of this paper is to investigate the mechanisms through which three local landholder groups in south-eastern Australia collectively manage weeds and the measures they use to evaluate success. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with members of three Landcare groups-Jerrawa Creek/Upper Lachlan, MacLaughlin River and Towamba Valley-as well as government staff external to the groups. The results reveal that for all three groups collective weed control is about supporting individual weed control efforts as well as proactively engaging landholders with the worst infestations. The groups were seen to be successful because they focused on the common challenge that weeds pose to all landholders, thereby removing the shame associated with having weeds, and because they organised community events that were as much about building and maintaining social relationships as improving weed control. Groups were positive about what they had achieved as collectives of landholders, but also saw an important role for government in providing funding, engaging with landholders who were unwilling to engage directly with the group, and controlling weeds on public lands.
二十年来,研究人员和政策制定者一直认为,需要以社区为基础的集体行动来有效控制杂草。然而,对于集体杂草控制在地方层面出现的方式,社会研究却很少。本文的目的是调查澳大利亚东南部三个当地土地所有者群体集体管理杂草的机制以及他们用于评估成功的措施。对三个土地保护组织(杰拉瓦溪/上拉克伦、麦克劳林河和托万巴山谷)的成员以及这些组织外部的政府工作人员进行了半结构化访谈。结果显示,对于所有这三个群体而言,集体杂草控制既包括支持个体的杂草控制努力,也包括积极让受杂草侵害最严重的土地所有者参与进来。这些群体被视为成功的,是因为它们关注杂草给所有土地所有者带来的共同挑战,从而消除了与杂草相关的羞耻感,还因为它们组织的社区活动既关乎建立和维护社会关系,也关乎改善杂草控制。各群体对作为土地所有者集体所取得的成就持积极态度,但也认为政府在提供资金、与不愿直接与该群体接触的土地所有者打交道以及控制公共土地上的杂草方面可发挥重要作用。