CH2M, 3011 SW Williston Rd, Gainesville, FL 32608, United States.
CH2M, 9191 South Jamaica Street, Englewood, CO 80112-5946, United States.
J Environ Manage. 2017 Dec 15;204(Pt 2):730-737. doi: 10.1016/j.jenvman.2017.03.097. Epub 2017 Apr 5.
In the ramp-up to integrating sustainability into remediation, a key industry focus area has been to reduce the environmental footprint of treatment processes. The typical approach to integrating sustainability into remediation projects has been a top-down approach, which involves developing technology options and then applying sustainability thinking to the technology, after it has been conceptualized. A bottom-up approach allows for systems thinking to be included in remedy selection and could potentially result in new or different technologies being considered. When using a bottom-up approach, there is room to consider the utilization of waste materials, non-refined materials, and renewable energy in remediation technology-all of which generally have a smaller footprint than processed materials and traditional forms of energy. By integrating more systems thinking into remediation projects, practitioners can think beyond the traditional technologies typically used and how technologies are deployed. To compare top-down and bottom-up thinking, a traditional technology that is considered very sustainable-enhanced in situ bioremediation-is compared to a successful, but infrequently deployed technology-subgrade biogeochemical reactors. Life Cycle Assessment is used for the evaluation and shows the footprint of the subgrade biogeochemical reactor to be lower in all seven impact categories evaluated, sometimes to a significant degree.
在将可持续性纳入修复的逐步推进过程中,一个关键的行业重点领域是减少处理过程对环境的影响。将可持续性纳入修复项目的典型方法是自上而下的方法,涉及开发技术选项,然后在技术概念化之后应用可持续性思维。自下而上的方法允许在补救措施选择中包含系统思维,并可能导致考虑新的或不同的技术。使用自下而上的方法时,可以考虑在修复技术中利用废物、非精制材料和可再生能源——所有这些通常比加工材料和传统形式的能源对环境的影响更小。通过将更多的系统思维纳入修复项目,从业者可以超越传统技术的使用方式和技术的部署方式进行思考。为了比较自上而下和自下而上的思维,将一种被认为非常可持续的传统技术——强化原位生物修复,与一种成功但很少部署的技术——底土生物地球化学反应器进行了比较。生命周期评估用于评估,并表明底土生物地球化学反应器在所有评估的七个影响类别中的足迹都较低,有时甚至是显著的。