Department of Medical Humanities, EMGO+ Institute for Health and Care Research, VU University Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Med Educ. 2017 May;51(5):521-530. doi: 10.1111/medu.13302.
Medical schools increasingly value and focus on teaching students intercultural competency within present-day multicultural society. Little is known about the experiences of cultural minority students in intercultural competence activities.
This article discusses the intercultural competence activities of medical education in a Dutch university from the perspective of cultural minority students. We will formulate recommendations for how to stimulate intercultural competency in, as well as inclusiveness of, medical education.
A qualitative evaluation was performed within a medical school in the Netherlands. Data were collected through interviews (n = 23), a focus group (six participants) and participant observations (20 hours). Thematic analysis was performed.
Cultural minority students experienced a lack of respect and understanding by cultural majority students and teachers. Education activities intended to transfer intercultural knowledge, address personal prejudice and stimulate intercultural sensitivity were perceived as stigmatising and as creating an unsafe climate for cultural minority students. Cultural minority and majority students on campus seemed segregated and the intercultural awareness of minority students was not integrated in intercultural competence activities.
As cultural minority students were confronted with microaggressions, the medical school did not succeed in creating a safe education environment for all students. Contrary to their aims and intentions, intercultural competence activities had limited effect and seemed to support the polarisation of cultural minority and majority students and teachers. This can be seen as pointing towards a hidden curriculum privileging majority over minority students. For structural integration of intercultural competency in medical education, the focus must penetrate beyond curricular activities towards the critical addressing of the culture and structure of medical school. Collective commitment to creating a safe and inclusive education climate is vital. This requires fostering social cohesion between minority and majority students and teachers, raising awareness and the practice by all involved of critical (self-)reflexivity on cultural prejudice and dominant, exclusionary norms in academic medicine.
医学院越来越重视并专注于在当今多元文化社会中教授学生跨文化能力。鲜少有人了解少数族裔学生在跨文化能力活动中的体验。
本文从少数族裔学生的角度讨论了荷兰一所大学医学教育中的跨文化能力活动。我们将提出如何在医学教育中激发跨文化能力以及包容性的建议。
在荷兰的一所医学院内进行了定性评估。通过访谈(n=23)、焦点小组(六名参与者)和参与式观察(20 小时)收集数据。进行了主题分析。
少数族裔学生经历了文化多数学生和教师的不尊重和不理解。旨在传授跨文化知识、解决个人偏见和激发跨文化敏感性的教育活动被视为污名化,并为少数族裔学生创造了不安全的氛围。校园内的少数族裔和多数族裔学生似乎是隔离的,少数族裔学生的跨文化意识并未融入跨文化能力活动中。
由于少数族裔学生面临着微侵犯,医学院未能为所有学生创造一个安全的教育环境。与他们的目标和意图相反,跨文化能力活动的效果有限,似乎支持了少数族裔和多数族裔学生和教师的两极分化。这可以被视为指向一个有利于多数族裔学生的隐性课程。为了在医学教育中结构性地融入跨文化能力,重点必须超越课程活动,深入探讨医学院的文化和结构。集体致力于创造一个安全和包容的教育氛围至关重要。这需要促进少数族裔和多数族裔学生和教师之间的社会凝聚力,提高所有相关人员对文化偏见和主导性、排他性规范的认识,并在学术医学中进行批判性(自我)反思的实践。