Department of Food and Nutrition, and Sport Science, Gothenburg, Sweden.
Army-Baylor University, San Antonio, Texas, USA.
Int J Ment Health Nurs. 2018 Apr;27(2):581-592. doi: 10.1111/inm.12339. Epub 2017 Apr 10.
Swedish mental health-care services are experiencing a critical shortage of nursing personnel. Researchers suggest that this shortage is due to low levels of job satisfaction. Job satisfaction is frequently studied with the assistance of Herzberg's two-factor theory, and this theory has foremost been explored with studies using quantitative methods. The purpose of the present study was to provide a better understanding of Herzberg's theory in relation to job satisfaction among Swedish mental health nursing personnel within inpatient psychiatric care while using qualitative methodology. This explorative study was based on semistructured interviews with 25 nursing personnel. Qualitative content analysis of interview transcripts identified three main categories: (i) respondents' perception of their work duties, which was perceived as important, meaningful, and demanding; (ii) respondents' relations with colleagues and supervisors, which provided valuable support in everyday work; and (iii) the way the respondents experienced their professional role as mental health nurses, which was described as unclear and vague. Job satisfaction primarily stemmed from working for patients and with other professionals, but their perceived limited progression of responsibilities discouraged a career in the profession. Herzberg's theory proved useful in exploring job satisfaction in this setting, but the findings partly contradict the basic tenets of the theory. Career advancements and incentives, such as salary and compensation, were perceived as lacking, which negatively influenced job satisfaction. Ward managers should establish clinical ladder programmes to recognize and motivate the continuing professional development of nurses. This needs to be coupled with monetary incentives, and linked with increased clinical authority.
瑞典的精神卫生保健服务正面临护理人员严重短缺的问题。研究人员认为,这种短缺是由于工作满意度低造成的。工作满意度经常在 Herzberg 的双因素理论的帮助下进行研究,而这一理论主要是通过使用定量方法的研究来探索的。本研究的目的是通过使用定性方法,在住院精神病护理中,更好地理解 Herzberg 理论与瑞典精神卫生护理人员的工作满意度之间的关系。这项探索性研究基于对 25 名护理人员的半结构化访谈。对访谈记录的定性内容分析确定了三个主要类别:(i) 受访者对其工作职责的看法,他们认为这些工作职责是重要的、有意义的和要求高的;(ii) 受访者与同事和主管的关系,这些关系为日常工作提供了有价值的支持;(iii) 受访者对自己作为精神健康护士的职业角色的体验,这被描述为不明确和模糊。工作满意度主要源于为患者和其他专业人员工作,但他们认为自己的责任进展有限,这阻碍了他们从事该职业。Herzberg 的理论在探索这一环境中的工作满意度方面是有用的,但调查结果在某种程度上与该理论的基本原则相矛盾。职业发展和激励措施,如薪酬和补偿,被认为是缺乏的,这对工作满意度产生了负面影响。病房经理应该建立临床阶梯计划,以认可和激励护士的持续专业发展。这需要与货币激励措施相结合,并与增加的临床权限联系起来。