Pannor Silver Michelle, Easty Laura K
Institute of Health Policy, Management and Evaluation (Pannor Silver, Easty); Department of Health Studies/Anthropology (Pannor Silver), University of Toronto, Toronto, Ont.
CMAJ Open. 2017 Feb 13;5(1):E123-E129. doi: 10.9778/cmajo.20160133. eCollection 2017 Jan-Mar.
Evidence suggests there are important personal and social consequences associated with inadequate retirement planning for physicians. We evaluated whether academic physicians felt satisfied with their retirement planning, and identified obstacles to retirement planning and a set of factors to facilitate retirement planning.
We applied a sequential mixed-methods research design to explore and examine factors that facilitate academic physician retirement planning using data collected from multiple sources (including 7 focus groups, an internet-based survey and 23 in-depth interviews). We examined survey results regarding retirement planning satisfaction and preferences for complete versus gradual retirement. We used thematic analysis to examine verbatim transcripts and notes from the focus groups and interviews.
Survey data (response rate 51%) indicated that 10% of respondents were very satisfied with their retirement planning and 89.5% would prefer to retire gradually rather than stop work completely. Key barriers to retirement planning that emerged included poor personal financial management, rigid institutional structures and professional norms. Facilitators included financial planning resources for physicians at multiple career stages, opportunities and resources for later-career transitions and later-career mentorship support for intergenerational collaboration, and recognition of retirees.
Key findings highlight perceived barriers to retirement planning at various career stages in addition to factors that can enhance physicians' retirement planning, including creating gradual and flexible retirement options, supporting ongoing discussions about financial planning and later career transitions, and fostering a culture that continues to honour and involve retirees. Medical institutions could foster innovative models for later-career transitions from medicine in ways that address physicians' needs at various career stages, support gradual transitions from practice and recognize the value of experienced, capable later-career physicians and retirees.
有证据表明,医生退休规划不足会带来重要的个人和社会后果。我们评估了学术型医生对其退休规划是否满意,确定了退休规划的障碍以及一系列有助于退休规划的因素。
我们采用了序贯混合方法研究设计,利用从多个来源收集的数据(包括7个焦点小组、一项基于互联网的调查和23次深入访谈)来探索和检验有助于学术型医生退休规划的因素。我们研究了关于退休规划满意度以及完全退休与渐进式退休偏好的调查结果。我们使用主题分析来研究焦点小组和访谈的逐字记录和笔记。
调查数据(回复率51%)表明,10%的受访者对其退休规划非常满意,89.5%的受访者更倾向于渐进式退休而非完全停止工作。出现的退休规划关键障碍包括个人财务管理不善、僵化的机构结构和职业规范。促进因素包括为处于多个职业阶段的医生提供财务规划资源、为职业后期转型提供机会和资源、为代际合作提供职业后期指导支持以及对退休人员的认可。
主要发现突出了不同职业阶段退休规划的感知障碍以及可以增强医生退休规划的因素,包括创造渐进式和灵活的退休选择、支持关于财务规划和职业后期转型的持续讨论,以及营造一种继续尊重并让退休人员参与其中的文化。医疗机构可以以满足医生在不同职业阶段需求的方式,培育创新的职业后期从医转型模式,支持从执业的渐进式转型,并认可经验丰富、能力出众的职业后期医生和退休人员的价值。