Tseng Jennifer, Kyrillos Alexandra, Liederbach Erik, Spear Georgia G, Ecanow Jacob, Wang Chi-Hsiung, Czechura Tom, Kantor Olga, Miller Megan, Winchester David J, Pesce Catherine E, Rabbitt Sarah, Yao Katharine
Department of Surgery, University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois.
Department of Surgery, NorthShore University Health System, Evanston, Illinois.
J Surg Oncol. 2017 Jun;115(8):924-931. doi: 10.1002/jso.24616. Epub 2017 Apr 13.
It is unclear if breast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is more accurate than mammography (MGM) and ultrasound (U/S) in aggregate for patients with invasive cancer.
We compared concordance of combined tumor size and tumor foci between MRI and MGM and U/S combined to pathological tumor size and foci as the gold standard from 2009 to 2015. Tumor size was nonconcordant if it differed from the pathologic size by ≥33% and tumor foci was nonconcordant if >1 foci were seen. If one or both of the MGM or U/S was nonconcordant and the MRI was concordant, MRI provided greater accuracy.
Of 471 patients with MGM, US, and MRI, MRI was more accurate for 32.9% of patients for tumor size and for 21.9% for tumor foci. Patients for whom MRI had greater accuracy were compared to those who did not for clinical and tumor factors. The only significant factor was calcifications on mammography. Tumor size, stage, molecular subtype, histology, grade, patient BMI, age, mammographic density, and use of hormone replacement therapy were not significantly different.
Breast MRI provides greater accuracy for a third of patients undergoing preoperative MGM and U/S. Mammographic calcifications were associated with MRI clinical accuracy for patients with invasive cancer.
对于浸润性癌患者,乳腺磁共振成像(MRI)在总体上是否比乳腺X线摄影(MGM)和超声(U/S)更准确尚不清楚。
我们比较了2009年至2015年间,MRI与MGM及U/S联合检查所显示的肿瘤大小和病灶数量与作为金标准的病理肿瘤大小和病灶数量之间的一致性。如果肿瘤大小与病理大小相差≥33%,则肿瘤大小不一致;如果发现>1个病灶,则肿瘤病灶不一致。如果MGM或U/S其中之一或两者均不一致而MRI一致,则MRI提供更高的准确性。
在471例接受MGM、US和MRI检查的患者中,MRI在肿瘤大小方面对32.9%的患者更准确,在肿瘤病灶方面对21.9%的患者更准确。将MRI准确性更高的患者与准确性不高的患者在临床和肿瘤因素方面进行比较。唯一显著的因素是乳腺X线摄影上的钙化。肿瘤大小、分期、分子亚型、组织学、分级、患者体重指数、年龄、乳腺X线摄影密度以及激素替代疗法的使用情况均无显著差异。
乳腺MRI为三分之一接受术前MGM和U/S检查的患者提供了更高的准确性。乳腺X线摄影钙化与浸润性癌患者的MRI临床准确性相关。