University of California San Francisco, Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, San Francisco, California.
Uni-versity Washington, Department of Radiology, Seattle, Washington.
Neurosurgery. 2018 Mar 1;82(3):343-349. doi: 10.1093/neuros/nyx167.
High-risk components of brain arteriovenous malformations (BAVMs) can be targeted to reduce the risk of lesion rupture.
To evaluate targeted embolization of aneurysms against other means of treatment with a case-control analysis; we previously investigated this approach associated with BAVMs.
Retrospective analysis of patients with BAVMs was performed, identifying patients treated with intention to occlude only an aneurysm associated with a BAVM. For each targeted aneurysm embolization (TAE) patient identified, 4 control patients were randomly selected, controlling for rupture status, age, and Spetzler-Martin plus Lawton-Young supplemental score. Analysis was performed to compare rates of adverse events (hemorrhage, new seizure, and death) between the 2 groups.
Thirty-two patients met inclusion criteria, and 128 control patients were identified, out of 1103 patients treated during the study period. Thirty-four adverse events occurred (15 ruptures, 15 new seizures, and 11 deaths) during the follow-up period (mean 1157 d for the TAE cohort and 1036 d for the non-TAE cohort). Statistically lower associations were noted for the TAE group for any adverse event (hazard ratio 0.28, P = .037) and the composite outcome of hemorrhage or new seizure (hazard ratio 0.20, P = .029).
For BAVMs at high risk for surgical resection, TAE can be performed safely and effectively. Patients treated with TAE had better outcomes than matched patients undergoing other combinations of treatment. TAE can be considered for BAVMs with high operative risk prior to radiosurgery or when no other treatment options are available.
高风险的脑动静脉畸形(BAVM)成分可以作为靶点,以降低病变破裂的风险。
通过病例对照分析评估针对动脉瘤的靶向栓塞治疗与其他治疗方法的效果;我们之前已经研究过这种方法与 BAVM 相关联的情况。
对 BAVM 患者进行回顾性分析,确定仅意图闭塞与 BAVM 相关联的动脉瘤的患者。为每个确定的靶向动脉瘤栓塞(TAE)患者,随机选择 4 名对照患者,对破裂状态、年龄和 Spetzler-Martin 加 Lawton-Young 补充评分进行控制。对两组之间不良事件(出血、新发性癫痫和死亡)的发生率进行分析比较。
在研究期间,共纳入了 32 名符合纳入标准的患者和 128 名对照患者,在 1103 名患者中进行了治疗。在随访期间(TAE 队列的平均随访时间为 1157d,非 TAE 队列为 1036d)发生了 34 例不良事件(15 例破裂、15 例新发性癫痫和 11 例死亡)。TAE 组的任何不良事件(风险比 0.28,P=.037)和出血或新发性癫痫的复合结局(风险比 0.20,P=.029)的关联明显较低。
对于高手术切除风险的 BAVM,TAE 可以安全有效地进行。接受 TAE 治疗的患者比接受其他治疗组合的匹配患者的预后更好。在进行放射外科治疗之前或在没有其他治疗选择的情况下,可以考虑对高手术风险的 BAVM 进行 TAE。