Monash Business School, Monash University, Caulfield East, Victoria, Australia.
Br J Soc Psychol. 2017 Dec;56(4):809-818. doi: 10.1111/bjso.12197. Epub 2017 Apr 16.
Some prior research has suggested that exposure to the American flag tilts Americans towards Republicanism, while others have proffered that it brings outs a common 'together' perspective instead. We explore a third possibility - that it may actually polarize Americans' political ideology. It is generally accepted that exposure to an environmental cue can shift attitudes and behaviours, at least partly or temporarily, in a manner that is consistent with that cue. Yet, the same cue can mean different things to different people. In the same vein, given how national identity and political ideology are intertwined in the United States, we hypothesize that the American flag should heighten different political beliefs depending on individuals' political ideology. To Democrats, being American is to support Democratic values, but to Republicans, being American is to support Republican values. The American flag thus should heighten Democrats of their Democratic identity, and it should heighten Republicans of their Republican one. The results of an experiment with 752 American respondents who were representative of the US population supported this polarizing effect of the American flag. The theoretical and policy implications of the findings are offered.
一些先前的研究表明,接触美国国旗会使美国人倾向于共和党,而另一些研究则认为它带来了一种共同的“团结”观点。我们探讨了第三种可能性——它实际上可能使美国人的政治意识形态两极化。人们普遍认为,环境线索的暴露至少在一定程度上或暂时地以与该线索一致的方式改变态度和行为。然而,同样的线索对不同的人可能意味着不同的东西。同样,鉴于在美国,国家身份和政治意识形态是交织在一起的,我们假设美国国旗应该根据个人的政治意识形态来增强不同的政治信仰。对民主党人来说,作为美国人就是支持民主党的价值观,但对共和党人来说,作为美国人就是支持共和党的价值观。因此,美国国旗应该增强民主党的民主意识,也应该增强共和党的共和意识。一项针对 752 名具有代表性的美国受访者的实验结果支持了美国国旗的这种极化效应。研究结果提供了理论和政策方面的启示。